AA to Discontinue JFK-BUD, Add Fourth DFW-LHR Flight
#46
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: May 2004
Location: DFW/DAL
Programs: AA Lifetime PLT, AS MVPG, HH Diamond, NCL Platinum Plus, MSC Diamond
Posts: 21,422
Somebody has got to explain to me why AA isn't serving TLV directly. . .
CO, DL, US . . . . they are all there - and doing quite well . . . and BA, LX and LH have tons of one-stop feeder traffic between TLV and the US.
Even if AA has to pick up the TWA obligations or whatever - the potential has got to be enormous. Why don't they even look at it?
CO, DL, US . . . . they are all there - and doing quite well . . . and BA, LX and LH have tons of one-stop feeder traffic between TLV and the US.
Even if AA has to pick up the TWA obligations or whatever - the potential has got to be enormous. Why don't they even look at it?
#47
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: IAH/HOU
Programs: AA Gold 1MM, UA 1K
Posts: 433
Somebody has got to explain to me why AA isn't serving TLV directly. . .
CO, DL, US . . . . they are all there - and doing quite well . . . and BA, LX and LH have tons of one-stop feeder traffic between TLV and the US.
Even if AA has to pick up the TWA obligations or whatever - the potential has got to be enormous. Why don't they even look at it?
CO, DL, US . . . . they are all there - and doing quite well . . . and BA, LX and LH have tons of one-stop feeder traffic between TLV and the US.
Even if AA has to pick up the TWA obligations or whatever - the potential has got to be enormous. Why don't they even look at it?
#48
Suspended
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Watchlisted by the prejudiced, en route to purgatory
Programs: Just Say No to Fleecing and Blacklisting
Posts: 102,095
Not a surprise, including for reasons related to that mentioned in the "expansion" thread rather recently.
Unlikely to be the issue but imagination is everyone's right.
Unlikely to be the issue but imagination is everyone's right.
#49
Original Poster
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: New York
Programs: AA Concierge Key, Marriott Titanium Elite, National Executive Elite
Posts: 326
As for the new LHR route, it is probably one of the best options we had for the 763 right now, leveraging our current assets to deploy the aircraft on a route that will have many revenue advantages, especially with our joint venture. It is far from simple to start a new route to a city we do not currently serve. It is also way to easy to say that we should do X, Y, and Z routes without knowing all of the factors involved. Given more time, options can be fully accessed as to where a 763 would be better served in our European network and an implementation plan can be executed.
Meanwhile, we have one little issue to resolve. It's called chapter 11... Things you see may not look so great now, but there is very bright future ahead!
#50
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: MHT/BOS
Programs: Many
Posts: 429
AA metal to Europe excluding LHR:
JFK-CDG 2x
JFK-MAN 1x
JFK-BRU 1x
JFK-ZRH 1x
JFK-MXP 1x
JFK-FCO 1x
JFK-BCN 1x
JFK-MAD 1x
ORD-HEL 1x
ORD-DUB 1x
ORD-MAN 1x
ORD-CDG 1x
ORD-FCO 1x
DFW-FRA 1x
DFW-CDG 1x
DFW-MAD 1x
MIA-CDG 1x
MIA-MAD 1x
BOS-CDG 1x
JFK-CDG 2x
JFK-MAN 1x
JFK-BRU 1x
JFK-ZRH 1x
JFK-MXP 1x
JFK-FCO 1x
JFK-BCN 1x
JFK-MAD 1x
ORD-HEL 1x
ORD-DUB 1x
ORD-MAN 1x
ORD-CDG 1x
ORD-FCO 1x
DFW-FRA 1x
DFW-CDG 1x
DFW-MAD 1x
MIA-CDG 1x
MIA-MAD 1x
BOS-CDG 1x
#51
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: May 2001
Location: LAX; AA EXP, MM; HH Gold
Posts: 31,789
Funny to read the 'No More LHR" posts here.
In the early '80s, when the domestic trunk airlines won the freedom to fly overseas (challenging the duopoly held by TWA and Pan Am), AA tried flying to a few second-tier European cities until it bought the rights to LHR from TWA. Over the next 20 years, AA expanded its service to London and trimmed its offerings to secondary cities.
DL acquired the European operations from Pan Am; CO and US built up substantial schedules to Europe. Wonder why those airlines did that?
Because they couldn't fly to Heathrow like AA and UA. And once AA could fly to Heathrow, it de-emphasized those other European cities.
For all of London's faults, it's by far the most popular business destination in Europe. Now that BA and AA have finally achieved their ATI, it's not just "stupid AA management" that is guiding these decisions - it's BA as well. If more money could be made by flying to some secondary cities instead of LHR, then BA and AA would do that and share those outsized profits instead. The fact that LHR gets another flight from DFW tells me that's where AA and BA think money can best be made.
AA flies an amazing number of premium seats to London every day. So many that there are frequently leftovers available for upgrades. If the price of easy transatlantic upgrades is having to connect in London - I'll gladly pay that price.
Over at DL, there are lots of one-per-day flights to secondary cities but unfortunately, DL's price for upgrading is an M fare or better.
All is not lost, however. AA flies to MAD and BCN and MXP and FCO and a few other fun places in addition to London. Perhaps with lower costs in the future, AA will fly to more of these cities.
In the early '80s, when the domestic trunk airlines won the freedom to fly overseas (challenging the duopoly held by TWA and Pan Am), AA tried flying to a few second-tier European cities until it bought the rights to LHR from TWA. Over the next 20 years, AA expanded its service to London and trimmed its offerings to secondary cities.
DL acquired the European operations from Pan Am; CO and US built up substantial schedules to Europe. Wonder why those airlines did that?
Because they couldn't fly to Heathrow like AA and UA. And once AA could fly to Heathrow, it de-emphasized those other European cities.
For all of London's faults, it's by far the most popular business destination in Europe. Now that BA and AA have finally achieved their ATI, it's not just "stupid AA management" that is guiding these decisions - it's BA as well. If more money could be made by flying to some secondary cities instead of LHR, then BA and AA would do that and share those outsized profits instead. The fact that LHR gets another flight from DFW tells me that's where AA and BA think money can best be made.
AA flies an amazing number of premium seats to London every day. So many that there are frequently leftovers available for upgrades. If the price of easy transatlantic upgrades is having to connect in London - I'll gladly pay that price.
Over at DL, there are lots of one-per-day flights to secondary cities but unfortunately, DL's price for upgrading is an M fare or better.
All is not lost, however. AA flies to MAD and BCN and MXP and FCO and a few other fun places in addition to London. Perhaps with lower costs in the future, AA will fly to more of these cities.
#52
Join Date: Nov 2010
Posts: 102
I wish they would have made this new DFW-LHR flight a Day flight to LHR. I love those out of ORD,JFK and BOS.
#53
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: San Francisco, CA
Programs: AA (PPro/3MM/Admirals Club), AS, UA, Marriott (Gold), HHonors (Gold), Accor (Plat)
Posts: 2,602
Getting ready for a RT SFO-LAX-LHR next week in C (J).
#54
Join Date: Sep 2011
Programs: AA SPG Amex
Posts: 4,644
However, as has been stated here MANY times: just because a flight is profitable doesn't mean that there are not more profitable uses of the aircraft out there. Just filling the hold of a 777 on SDQ could be profitable; $1,000 ahead is a profit, but it's nothing compared to the many multiples of that AA can make by flying a plane full of pax MIA-GRU.
#55
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: SF Bay Area
Programs: Marriott Bonvoy Ambassador, AA EXP
Posts: 2,702
However, as has been stated here MANY times: just because a flight is profitable doesn't mean that there are not more profitable uses of the aircraft out there. Just filling the hold of a 777 on SDQ could be profitable; $1,000 ahead is a profit, but it's nothing compared to the many multiples of that AA can make by flying a plane full of pax MIA-GRU.
#56
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: IND/NYC/MEX
Programs: AA PPro BA Bronze SPG Gold HH GLD Hyatt Exp
Posts: 1,133
Add me to the list hoping for a new Europe non-LHR route. AMS would be nice, but is doubtful. I will also don the BER rose colored glasses. Or how about something else in the Ruhr Valley?
#57
Join Date: Sep 2011
Programs: AA SPG Amex
Posts: 4,644
Your logic is faulty; AA has substantial overhead not attributable to any particular flight or route. The revenues from each flight could be greater than the direct costs of that flight (crew, fuel, ground staff specific to the flight) but still not cover the costs accrued by AA that are spread over all flights (or large groups of flights). A D check on a 763 is expensive but cannot be assigned to any one flight...
#58
Join Date: May 2004
Location: San Francisco, CA
Programs: AA EXP 1MM, UA 1K, Marriott/SPG Platinum Elite
Posts: 774
#59
Join Date: Nov 2009
Programs: AA PLT, 60K "old miles"
Posts: 188
Originally Posted by FWAAA All is not lost, however. AA flies to MAD and BCN and MXP and FCO and a few other fun places in addition to London. Perhaps with lower costs in the future, AA will fly to more of these cities.[/QUOTE]
I hope so. It is sad to see Delhi and Budapest go. Over the past 5 years well over half my miles have been international. That will go to 80% or 90% in the near future.
IMHO don't need more flights to London, need more connections through MAD and AA flights to good places.
Shopping. Will fly BA 1st class to JBurg this summer and probably Emirates to Delhi in the fall.
The continuing lament of American companies is that they can't make money where others step in and seem to do fine ( or new american companies like Jet Blue come in and dominate old strongholds). So they look for places to cut back to become profitable.
Reality is reality. Hope AAL can create something positive post banktruptcy.
I hope so. It is sad to see Delhi and Budapest go. Over the past 5 years well over half my miles have been international. That will go to 80% or 90% in the near future.
IMHO don't need more flights to London, need more connections through MAD and AA flights to good places.
Shopping. Will fly BA 1st class to JBurg this summer and probably Emirates to Delhi in the fall.
The continuing lament of American companies is that they can't make money where others step in and seem to do fine ( or new american companies like Jet Blue come in and dominate old strongholds). So they look for places to cut back to become profitable.
Reality is reality. Hope AAL can create something positive post banktruptcy.
#60
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: BOS
Posts: 519
Berlin is a low yield tourist market. there is very little high yield traffic there, regardless of this new airport. And Air Berlin doesnt really have that many nonstops from there besides for flights to/from Palma, Mallorca. Believe it or not, Palma, Mallorca, NOT Berlin, is their main base.
I really do not know why OneWorld went after Air Berlin. While the service is good, it's a low yield airline flying mainly leisure routes. This does not fare well for an AA flight into Berlin.
I really do not know why OneWorld went after Air Berlin. While the service is good, it's a low yield airline flying mainly leisure routes. This does not fare well for an AA flight into Berlin.
Connections from Berlin aren't bad at all. Here's the direct flights from TXL today, and AB will add routes once BER opens.
Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates
Alicante, Spain
Antalya, Turkey
Bangkok, Thailand
Barcelona, Spain
Bari, Italy
Basle, Switzerland
Catania, Italy
Cologne, Germany
Copenhagen, Denmark
Dubai, United Arab Emirates
Düsseldorf, Germany
Enfidha, Tunisia
Frankfurt, Germany
Funchal, Portugal
Gothenburg, Sweden
Graz, Austria
Helsinki, Finland
Hurghada, Egypt
Innsbruck, Austria
Karlsruhe, Germany
Kraków, Poland
Lanzarote, Spain
Linz, Austria
Luxor, Egypt
Malaga, Spain
Miami, FL
Milan, Italy
Moscow, Russia
Munich, Germany
Münster, Germany
New York, NY
Nuernberg, Germany
Olbia, Italy
Oslo, Norway
Palma, Spain
Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain
Phuket, Thailand
Puerto del Rosario, Spain
Punta Cana, Dominican Republic
Rome, Italy
Saarbrücken, Germany
Saint Petersburg, Russia
Salzburg, Austria
Santa Cruz de La Palma, Spain
Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt
Stockholm, Sweden
Stuttgart, Germany
Tel Aviv, Israel
Tenerife South Airport (TFS), Spain
Varadero, Cuba
Venice, Italy
Verona, Italy
Vienna, Austria
Zurich, Switzerland