recognition vs "one up"?
#31
Join Date: May 2008
Location: MSP
Programs: DL Plat, NZ Elite, QF Plat
Posts: 1,776
It seems the problem child are RUs and Elite APD upgrades lodged after T-7 days
Basically at T-7 days upgrades are allocated with OneUps at the bottom of the rank. I've been told that upgrades are only given in advance if there are 5 or more seats left in that cabin class.
From T-7 to T-8hours before departure it seems that OneUps are regularly reviewed but that RUs are only looked at at either T-7 or on the day of departure. Someone correct me if I'm wrong but the stories in this thread where OneUps are given over RUs are all in the situation where a RU is lodged within 7 days of departure (after that initial upgrade review and allocation) and that the OneUp system is reviewed multiple times before departure but the RUs are not? This is maybe because the software is set to assume that all RUs have been allocated by the time OneUps have been processed. Which would be true at T-7 but not at say T-3 if someone puts in an RU at T-4
Hopefully that makes some sense.
Basically at T-7 days upgrades are allocated with OneUps at the bottom of the rank. I've been told that upgrades are only given in advance if there are 5 or more seats left in that cabin class.
From T-7 to T-8hours before departure it seems that OneUps are regularly reviewed but that RUs are only looked at at either T-7 or on the day of departure. Someone correct me if I'm wrong but the stories in this thread where OneUps are given over RUs are all in the situation where a RU is lodged within 7 days of departure (after that initial upgrade review and allocation) and that the OneUp system is reviewed multiple times before departure but the RUs are not? This is maybe because the software is set to assume that all RUs have been allocated by the time OneUps have been processed. Which would be true at T-7 but not at say T-3 if someone puts in an RU at T-4
Hopefully that makes some sense.
#33
Join Date: Aug 2016
Posts: 229
[QUOTE=NZ_Flyer;28704832]It seems the problem child are RUs and Elite APD upgrades lodged after T-7 days
Basically at T-7 days upgrades are allocated with OneUps at the bottom of the rank. I've been told that upgrades are only given in advance if there are 5 or more seats left in that cabin class.
From T-7 to T-8hours before departure it seems that OneUps are regularly reviewed but that RUs are only looked at at either T-7 or on the day of departure. Someone correct me if I'm wrong but the stories in this thread where OneUps are given over RUs are all in the situation where a RU is lodged within 7 days of departure (after that initial upgrade review and allocation) and that the OneUp system is reviewed multiple times before departure but the RUs are not?
It is my my understanding that this is NOT the situation. My reading is that people have lodge RU requests well in advance of T-7; One-ups have been granted at T-7, but RUs have not. Then on day of departure, typically at check in or after checkin has closed, RUs clear. It might be argued "The RU came through and no One Up was granted while an RU was denied". It matters if you are not Gold or Elite, but using your one, hard-earned RU...and I know that many people on this forum think that the entire country are gold or elite...they're aren't!! You don't get to take advantage of increased baggage; you potentially don't get priority check in; you potentially don't get lounge access (if it clears at the gate). Cleared One-Ups get those benefits. If you are gold or Elite, it will not impact you, but if you are not, it certainly might well do.
Basically at T-7 days upgrades are allocated with OneUps at the bottom of the rank. I've been told that upgrades are only given in advance if there are 5 or more seats left in that cabin class.
From T-7 to T-8hours before departure it seems that OneUps are regularly reviewed but that RUs are only looked at at either T-7 or on the day of departure. Someone correct me if I'm wrong but the stories in this thread where OneUps are given over RUs are all in the situation where a RU is lodged within 7 days of departure (after that initial upgrade review and allocation) and that the OneUp system is reviewed multiple times before departure but the RUs are not?
It is my my understanding that this is NOT the situation. My reading is that people have lodge RU requests well in advance of T-7; One-ups have been granted at T-7, but RUs have not. Then on day of departure, typically at check in or after checkin has closed, RUs clear. It might be argued "The RU came through and no One Up was granted while an RU was denied". It matters if you are not Gold or Elite, but using your one, hard-earned RU...and I know that many people on this forum think that the entire country are gold or elite...they're aren't!! You don't get to take advantage of increased baggage; you potentially don't get priority check in; you potentially don't get lounge access (if it clears at the gate). Cleared One-Ups get those benefits. If you are gold or Elite, it will not impact you, but if you are not, it certainly might well do.
#34
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: NZ
Programs: NZ*E, QF-G, EK-P
Posts: 605
I dont profess to have any inside knowledge aside from a conversation with someone who works in their revenue control group - who don't do the upgrades but does have some oversight.
Practically all of the upgrades which are likely to work are processed at T-7 days in the order previously described. But majority aren't released until day of travel in case they have last minute sales - but the back-end process is completed earlier.
YMMV.
Practically all of the upgrades which are likely to work are processed at T-7 days in the order previously described. But majority aren't released until day of travel in case they have last minute sales - but the back-end process is completed earlier.
YMMV.
#35
Join Date: Apr 2013
Location: New Zealand (most of the time)
Programs: Air NZ Elite *G, Honors Gold, IHG Platinum Elite
Posts: 6,116
It is my my understanding that this is NOT the situation. My reading is that people have lodge RU requests well in advance of T-7; One-ups have been granted at T-7, but RUs have not. Then on day of departure, typically at check in or after checkin has closed, RUs clear. It might be argued "The RU came through and no One Up was granted while an RU was denied". It matters if you are not Gold or Elite, but using your one, hard-earned RU...and I know that many people on this forum think that the entire country are gold or elite...they're aren't!! You don't get to take advantage of increased baggage; you potentially don't get priority check in; you potentially don't get lounge access (if it clears at the gate). Cleared One-Ups get those benefits. If you are gold or Elite, it will not impact you, but if you are not, it certainly might well do.
As for baggage you get the baggage allowance of your upgraded class if a RU or APD is lodged - the only exception is Seats to Suit routes.
At the end of the day by far the vast majority of OneUp upgrades to not clear.
The vast majority of RU and APD upgrades do clear. There isn't much else to really add.
#37
Join Date: Aug 2016
Posts: 229
A scenario of a OneUp clearing in advance of travel while somebody waits until the gate for a RU to clear would be incredibly unlikely.
As for baggage you get the baggage allowance of your upgraded class if a RU or APD is lodged - the only exception is Seats to Suit routes.
At the end of the day by far the vast majority of OneUp upgrades to not clear.
The vast majority of RU and APD upgrades do clear. There isn't much else to really add.
As for baggage you get the baggage allowance of your upgraded class if a RU or APD is lodged - the only exception is Seats to Suit routes.
At the end of the day by far the vast majority of OneUp upgrades to not clear.
The vast majority of RU and APD upgrades do clear. There isn't much else to really add.
See above flysally and teabag for examples.
Hmmmm I wonder if Silver flyers AKL-LAX-AKL would agree with the assertion that the vast majority of RUs clear?
Of course we will never know that because of airnz's lack of transparency around upgrades,
I don't believe that it is a conspiracy. And I no longer have skin in this game. airnz lost me as a ff when they changed the rules around benefits to golds about 4 years ago. I now travel with them as a non-ff when there is no other option.
#38
Join Date: Apr 2013
Location: New Zealand (most of the time)
Programs: Air NZ Elite *G, Honors Gold, IHG Platinum Elite
Posts: 6,116
This has been policy for many years, and I'm not aware of it changing in the last few months. If you've got evidence of it changing I'd be keen to know.
As for RU's clearing my comment is what I said. The vast majority of RU's clear - I'm not talking about specific routes, it's an across the board statement.
For the record I know plenty of Silver pax who have had RU's clear on AKL-LAX or AKL to SFO flights. Just because some don't clear (and if you're an Elite travelling during busy times such as school holidays you probably won't get your upgrades clear either due to the planes being chokka) doesn't mean none clear.
I really don't understand what the "lack of transparency is". At the end of the day RU's are an unconfirmed upgrade. I understand perfectly how the system works, the only thing I don't know is where I rank in an upgrade list which is the only benefit of upgrade systems that most US airlines use where you can see your name and know what your chances of an upgrade are.
Last edited by sbiddle; Aug 20, 2017 at 2:49 am
#39
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Dunedin, New Zealand
Programs: Air New Zealand Airpoints - Gold Elite, Velocity - Platinum, Qantas - Gold
Posts: 180
I've believe this is correct. From what I've heard and my experiences, as long as you have lodged an upgrade for a long-haul route, you do receive the additional baggage allowance.
#40
Join Date: Dec 2012
Programs: NZ*S
Posts: 773
I believe NZ *S RUs are processed closer to the time. I have been told 3-5 days before the flight by Air NZ contact centre staff but I agree with sbiddle that this is probably done upon checkin or on the day of travel.
This leads me to the conclusion that an NZ *S RU is trumped by OneUp but not a NZ *E RU (even when gifted). I don't know enough about NZ *G RU to comment.
This leads me to the conclusion that an NZ *S RU is trumped by OneUp but not a NZ *E RU (even when gifted). I don't know enough about NZ *G RU to comment.
#42
Join Date: May 2008
Location: MSP
Programs: DL Plat, NZ Elite, QF Plat
Posts: 1,776
R for business premier
However Air NZ don't release availability of R class to ExpertFlyer so you have to call Air NZ up and check availability if you want to guarantee a confirmed advanced upgrade to Business Premier. They release 2x seats Business Premier seats per flight for Elite RU's/APD upgrades.
#43
Join Date: Jan 2013
Posts: 223
A for premium economy
R for business premier
However Air NZ don't release availability of R class to ExpertFlyer so you have to call Air NZ up and check availability if you want to guarantee a confirmed advanced upgrade to Business Premier. They release 2x seats Business Premier seats per flight for Elite RU's/APD upgrades.
R for business premier
However Air NZ don't release availability of R class to ExpertFlyer so you have to call Air NZ up and check availability if you want to guarantee a confirmed advanced upgrade to Business Premier. They release 2x seats Business Premier seats per flight for Elite RU's/APD upgrades.
#44
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: WLG/BKK
Programs: TG*G, NZ*GE, QF G, Accor Gold
Posts: 10,199
For a gifted RU from a NZ*E, does the booking have to have my Airpoints number entered into the frequent flyer data?
I presume the ticket needs to be on NZ stock, even if containing other sectors on other carriers.
I ask as I am TG*G but NZ nothing, and I could possibly be a NZ*E RU beneficary.
Thanks.
I presume the ticket needs to be on NZ stock, even if containing other sectors on other carriers.
I ask as I am TG*G but NZ nothing, and I could possibly be a NZ*E RU beneficary.
Thanks.
Last edited by Thai-Kiwi; Aug 24, 2017 at 7:25 am
#45
Join Date: Feb 2014
Location: Auckland
Programs: NZ*E
Posts: 186
For a gifted RU from a NZ*E, does the booking have to have my Airpoints number entered into the frequent flyer data?
I presume the ticket needs to be on NZ stock, even if containing other sectors on other carriers.
I ask as I am TG*G but NZ nothing, and I could possibly be a NZ*E RU beneficary.
Thanks.
I presume the ticket needs to be on NZ stock, even if containing other sectors on other carriers.
I ask as I am TG*G but NZ nothing, and I could possibly be a NZ*E RU beneficary.
Thanks.