FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Air Canada | Aeroplan (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/air-canada-aeroplan-375/)
-   -   ICN to YYZ...SQ vs AC (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/air-canada-aeroplan/1177233-icn-yyz-sq-vs-ac.html)

llbean Jan 26, 11 10:39 pm

ICN to YYZ...SQ vs AC
 
Asking for some advice/opinions...

I need to fly ICN to YYZ (flying OZ on the way there via ORD...no other choice)
Travels will be in J

I have two options:

1. ICN-SFO on SQ J (777) then SFO-YYZ on AC J (A320)

or

2. ICN-YVR-YYZ on 763 on AC J


Im a new SE and am partially tempted to take option 2 for double miles as I chose the 100% bonus. But how do they calculate miles on this route...is tit ICN-YVR-YYZ or ICN-YYZ. Of course SQ new J is awesome...and it seems a shame to turn it down!

The only other advantage of route 2 is that I get a pod all the way home (although I find them stuffy and hot at times..) vs a domestic J from SFO-YYZ if I take SQ.

I should mention that I fly AC J alot and its nice. I flew the new SQ J once before and it is a class above...

thoughts? what would you do?

mikeyyz Jan 26, 11 10:57 pm

Do you care about lifetime E? Do you really need the miles?

If not a strong yes, this is a hard one. I'd veer towards SQ J because I like the seat + food much better, as long as SFO-YYZ isn't a red-eye.

Mike

Stranger Jan 26, 11 11:00 pm

Depends if your priority is service or safety I guess.

llbean Jan 26, 11 11:04 pm


Originally Posted by Stranger (Post 15744032)
Depends if your priority is service or safety I guess.

safety???

I think both SQ and AC are safe!

djjaguar64 Jan 27, 11 6:18 am

I highly recommend you go with SQ, inflight service and food cannot be beat and the ambience is just perfect.

djjaguar64 Jan 27, 11 6:19 am


Originally Posted by Stranger (Post 15744032)
Depends if your priority is service or safety I guess.

A very lame response.:rolleyes:

airbus320 Jan 27, 11 6:23 am


Originally Posted by Stranger (Post 15744032)
Depends if your priority is service or safety I guess.

Please clarify your statement. :confused:

payam81 Jan 27, 11 6:28 am


Originally Posted by Stranger (Post 15744032)
Depends if your priority is service or safety I guess.

As the moderator reminded you in the other thread, this is not the OMNI forum. Do you want your posts yanked again?

mobilebucky Jan 27, 11 7:11 am

I choose option 2 just so I don't have to clear custom/immigration in US.

Is ICN-NRT-YYZ an option? That would be my first choice. All big jets all the way!

global happy traveller Jan 27, 11 7:19 am

personally i prefer SQ for long haul flights. book the cook, better wines and hot fishball noodles in between meals.... and great singapore sling! AC is good as well, but most of their mid flight snacks are packaged snacks with 1 or two quick prep ones

Academic Jan 27, 11 7:23 am


Originally Posted by global_happy_traveller (Post 15745567)
FYI if i recall ICN to North America flights on SQ are still SpaceBed and not the latest product.

This would be the deciding factor for me. Unless you can get the new Bus Class seats on SQ, AC would be the way to go.

Stranger Jan 27, 11 7:49 am


Originally Posted by llbean (Post 15744044)
safety???

I think both SQ and AC are safe!

No such a thing as "safe." There safer vs. less safe.

SQ's record is not great. TPE crash, also the Silkair suicidal pilot. If you look for instance at airsafe.com, AC comes up at 0.33. SQ at 1.50 and on a much smaller number of flights. Worse than for instance Air France.

TRAVELSIG Jan 27, 11 8:15 am

I would skip transit through the USA and go via YVR.

YOW_Flyer Jan 27, 11 8:16 am

I go for SQ J over AC J any time!

One thing to keep in mind is that clearing US immigration and customs at SFO can be a nightmare at times due to the arrival of many international flights at the same time. That would be the only drawback on the ICN-SFO-YYZ in my view. Not sure if you have a NEXUS card or not, if you do, you can now use the Global Entry, which will eliminate this drawback!

kellytoronto Jan 27, 11 8:23 am

SQ16 from ICN-SFO is the new J 77W. Another option to consider is OZ to NRT and back from there. If ease was my objective, I'd definitely do the ICN-YVR-YYZ: only one set of customs, and a quick exit at YYZ once you land after the long flight.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 6:27 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright 2021 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.