I stayed at Muchenje this past January and thought that it was great. The owners were super friendly (as were all the staff) and the guide I had for the 3 days/2 nights I was there went out of his way find the animals I wanted to see. The trip out on the boat on the Chobe was the best part of the safari. The small number of guests at the lodge during the green season also meant much smaller groups heading out on safari each day.

I found the Green season in Chobe to be full of animals and saw thousands along the river. The only downside of the green season appears to be the obvious fact that it is much more difficult to see animals in the bush--particularly the cats that are much smaller in numbers than the elephants, giraffe, zebra, etc.

Thank you @gspurr, your post is most helpful!!

go for the houseboat
 

During our Africa vacation in April we spent 2 nights on Pride of Zambezi houseboat and 2 nights at Elephant Valley Lodge. The houseboat was great-you board near Kasane. Viewing the animals from the water is great-they all come to the river to drink. There are 3 small houseboats and you can book them for as many nights as you want, even 1. I much preferred the water game drives to the land ones in the park.

http://www.prideofzambezi.com/

If you want to stay on land you can stay in a hotel in Kasane and get a guide to go into Chobe NP each day. The problem with EVL was it took 30 minutes each way to and from the lodge and park. With 2 game drives a day this was a lot of bouncing around in the truck.

Thanks. Yes, I know about the houseboats and but decided we'd prefer a lodge.

We are leaning towards Muchenje. We like its small size and support for the community. The reviews are excellent as well.