Separate PNR on Aegean - MAD - ATH - JTR (2:40 connection) saves $69 - advisable?
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Programs: AAdvantage Gold, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 132
Separate PNR on Aegean - MAD - ATH - JTR (2:40 connection) saves $69 - advisable?
Hi,
So am in a dilemma to book a single ticket with Aegean or buy two separate PNRs .
MAD - ATH - JTR
MAD-ATH: Aegean, ATH - JTR: Olympic airways
The flight that I am looking at, is 220 Euro/per person on 1 ticket, but if i split the ticket, buy MAD - ATH separately wtih ATH - JTR both from aegean website, they together come out to (99Euro + 59 Euro = 158 Euro). So savings of almost 62 Euro/ 69 USD per person. We are 2 travelers.
So am in a dilemma to book a single ticket with Aegean or buy two separate PNRs .
MAD - ATH - JTR
MAD-ATH: Aegean, ATH - JTR: Olympic airways
The flight that I am looking at, is 220 Euro/per person on 1 ticket, but if i split the ticket, buy MAD - ATH separately wtih ATH - JTR both from aegean website, they together come out to (99Euro + 59 Euro = 158 Euro). So savings of almost 62 Euro/ 69 USD per person. We are 2 travelers.
- Connection time between flights in Athens is 2 hours 40 minutes.
- Since MAD - ATH - JTR all in schengen zone, no customs/immigration right?
- If we miss the connection due to delay in MAD - ATH flights, there are 2 later flights on Olympic Air from ATH - JTR same day but we would risk buying walk up fares.
#2
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: MEL CHC
Posts: 21,017
Will you have checked luggage? If you do, will Aegean interline on separate tickets?
With separate tickets, you have 2:40 less the time that check-in and bag drop closes: say 45minutes?
For 2:40 between flights I would spend the €62
Presumably you have looked at other airlines
http://www.gcmap.com/mapui?P=MAD-ATH-JTR+&MS=wls&DU=mi
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santor...tional_Airport
With separate tickets, you have 2:40 less the time that check-in and bag drop closes: say 45minutes?
For 2:40 between flights I would spend the €62
Presumably you have looked at other airlines
http://www.gcmap.com/mapui?P=MAD-ATH-JTR+&MS=wls&DU=mi
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santor...tional_Airport
Last edited by Mwenenzi; Feb 2, 2020 at 1:05 pm
#3
Original Poster
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Programs: AAdvantage Gold, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 132
No checked luggage. We travel light so only 1 carry on. Not sure about interline but Olympic Air is a subsidiary of Aegean so hopefully yes. But since we don't plan on checked luggage, likely wont matter.
Other airlines are not feasible because of timing issues.
Other airlines are not feasible because of timing issues.
#4
Join Date: Mar 2018
Location: ARN
Programs: A3*G, SK*G
Posts: 336
Hi,
So am in a dilemma to book a single ticket with Aegean or buy two separate PNRs .
MAD - ATH - JTR
MAD-ATH: Aegean, ATH - JTR: Olympic airways
The flight that I am looking at, is 220 Euro/per person on 1 ticket, but if i split the ticket, buy MAD - ATH separately wtih ATH - JTR both from aegean website, they together come out to (99Euro + 59 Euro = 158 Euro). So savings of almost 62 Euro/ 69 USD per person. We are 2 travelers.
So am in a dilemma to book a single ticket with Aegean or buy two separate PNRs .
MAD - ATH - JTR
MAD-ATH: Aegean, ATH - JTR: Olympic airways
The flight that I am looking at, is 220 Euro/per person on 1 ticket, but if i split the ticket, buy MAD - ATH separately wtih ATH - JTR both from aegean website, they together come out to (99Euro + 59 Euro = 158 Euro). So savings of almost 62 Euro/ 69 USD per person. We are 2 travelers.
Connection time between flights in Athens is 2 hours 40 minutes.
Since MAD - ATH - JTR all in schengen zone, no customs/immigration right?
Is it worth risking to buy 2 separate tickets to save 69$/person given the information? would you guys do it?
These are my 2 cents, but this is your call. I suppose it all comes down to your risk tolerance, and how much you value that €158. If this wasn't sold as a single ticket, and you were offered instead the option to purchase misconnection insurance for $69 per person, would you do it?
Yes, normally they should interline. Although they do not HAVE to do it, there is no reason why they wouldn't. In my experience I've never had any problems interlining baggage within the same airline, in fact not even between different *A carriers. If OP needs to reclaim his bags, check them again, and go through security then this could be very time consuming. Especially so during the summer months, where most European airports turn into madhouses... Unless of course OP has status with *A.
#5
Moderator: Aegean Miles+Bonus
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: AMS / ATH
Programs: AFKL Plat, A3 Gold
Posts: 7,339
Almost all Schengen flights in Athens arrive at/depart from Terminal B, so basically you will just have to walk 5-10 mins max. I think that in peak times/seasons they may also use the Satellite terminal, but even that shouldn't be concern if your MAD-ATH flight is not severely delayed .
#6
Join Date: Mar 2018
Location: ARN
Programs: A3*G, SK*G
Posts: 336
I remember arriving there in summertime a couple of times, but it was quite sometime ago, so it could have well been when I was still flying DY occasionally...
#8
Suspended
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Canada, USA, Europe
Programs: UA 1K
Posts: 31,452
Your question about risk is probably one only you can answer. I see that you understand that you are not connecting and know that, if you miss the second flight that whole ticket will be cancelled and you'll have to buy a return ticket at walk-up prices. There is no what to build a risk model, because you can't meaningfully attribute a likelihood of cancellation or significant delay of the incoming flight. Nor can you predict weather.
So what you have to do is accept that there will either be outcome A (one ticket) which has a fixed cost of EUR 220 per person, or outcome B (separate tickets) which has a cost of either EUR 158 or EUR 158 + EUR 150 (? I'm guessing at a possible walk-up fare ATH-JTR). Personally, for the sake of less stress, I would book this as a single ticket.
So what you have to do is accept that there will either be outcome A (one ticket) which has a fixed cost of EUR 220 per person, or outcome B (separate tickets) which has a cost of either EUR 158 or EUR 158 + EUR 150 (? I'm guessing at a possible walk-up fare ATH-JTR). Personally, for the sake of less stress, I would book this as a single ticket.
#12
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: Wedged somewhere between BTS and VIE ✈
Programs: Star Alliance Gold (A3 Gold), Oneworld Emerald (BA Gold), Hilton Diamond
Posts: 6,338
I would also book the tickets separately, but I'm a tight git!
I do wonder whether in such a case Gold cardholders would be treated any differently if the connection was missed. I ask that because the situation did arise when flying BA, and they rebooked me onto a later flight free of charge - even though it was weather related. Of course all airlines are different, but it would be interesting to know.
It would also be interesting to know what time of year this booking is planned for?
I do wonder whether in such a case Gold cardholders would be treated any differently if the connection was missed. I ask that because the situation did arise when flying BA, and they rebooked me onto a later flight free of charge - even though it was weather related. Of course all airlines are different, but it would be interesting to know.
It would also be interesting to know what time of year this booking is planned for?
#13
Join Date: Apr 2019
Location: London
Posts: 192
Don't book it separately. It doesn't worth it.
Apart from all the usual delays, air traffic delays are very common during the summer season in Greece.
Did it last year with the same connection time, managed to reach the gate midway through boarding.
Apart from all the usual delays, air traffic delays are very common during the summer season in Greece.
Did it last year with the same connection time, managed to reach the gate midway through boarding.
#15
Join Date: Oct 2012
Location: PAS, Paros Greece
Programs: A3 *G
Posts: 1,372
I do this often and I almost always book two separate tickets (for the same reason). Obviously there COULD be a 2+hr delay on your inbound flight but that's extremely unlikely. Transferring intra-Schengen at Athens is a non-issue. It's very quick and seamless even though many/most flights involve a bus transfer to the terminal. NONE of the gates used by A3 or OA are more than a five minute walk from where the bus drops off (unless you have some disability of course).
Incidentally, the reason the through flights being more expenses is how the fare buckets work. Probably you'll find the ATH-JTR flight is in a higher fare bucket which forces the whole trip into that bucket, thus making the first flight a lot more expensive. I've found I can sometimes get around that by booking with an OTA, as others have mentioned. Other times it seems to be done deliberately. For example, I often fly PAS-ATH-CHQ and each flight is available in P class yet the combined trip prices as K class so 29 + 54 Euro quickly becomes 210 Euro! I just buy the two tickets and even on a 50 or 60 minute connection I have always found time to visit the lounge even.
As somebody else said - if you DO book ATH-JTR on a different ticket, don't book a return, book two singles - that way you won't also lose the JTR-ATH if things go wrong. Dover2Golf's advice above is an good idea too.
Incidentally, the reason the through flights being more expenses is how the fare buckets work. Probably you'll find the ATH-JTR flight is in a higher fare bucket which forces the whole trip into that bucket, thus making the first flight a lot more expensive. I've found I can sometimes get around that by booking with an OTA, as others have mentioned. Other times it seems to be done deliberately. For example, I often fly PAS-ATH-CHQ and each flight is available in P class yet the combined trip prices as K class so 29 + 54 Euro quickly becomes 210 Euro! I just buy the two tickets and even on a 50 or 60 minute connection I have always found time to visit the lounge even.
As somebody else said - if you DO book ATH-JTR on a different ticket, don't book a return, book two singles - that way you won't also lose the JTR-ATH if things go wrong. Dover2Golf's advice above is an good idea too.