Originally posted by Horizons:
1) American would not offer an automatic comp in AAdvantage at any level, but offered to enroll me in one of their
A couple of months ago I called American asking to be comp'ed to their equivalent of United Premier. The agent said "Sure" and gave me the fax number. I simply faxed a copy of my current mileage summary from UAL.com along with a cover letter request and the comp came through within a few days. Might be worth a try...