Originally Posted by
hhoope01
I think it is based more on a particular stay pattern. Basically, those that have stayed more within the past year or so, will get the higher end offers. Those who have stayed a moderate amount over the past year or so will get the middle offers. Those who have stayed fewer nights will get the low end offers.
Yup. I'm Plat, but I've spent a grand total of 3 paid nights at Marriotts this year, so I got the crappiest offer (3 stays for 5000 extra pts).

for me, but fairly understandable...