Hi,

I've got premier status on a couple airlines and am trying to decide which program to purchase lounge access through as my Northwest WorldClub membership expires. I'm thinking of United's Red Carpet Club, since it gives you access to some Star Alliance lounges.

I travel frequently from North America to Asia, but work for a nonprofit so have to fly coach. I'm looking to join a club with the least-restrictive access to decent lounges to while away the layovers in. (For instance, I want to avoid clubs that restrict your access to their lounge if you don't have a same-day boarding pass on one of their flights.) Thanks for any insights!