So the new J seat is just reverse herringbone with a door? What's innovative about that? It seems like other airlines are already ahead of this "new" product from AA. Look at ANA. Aside from the fact that their new seat is so hard that it feels like a park bench, it really is an impressive new design with a lot of space and privacy. (Now if someone would just tweak the seat padding to make it comfortable, it would be the best J seat in the sky.)