Hi Mike,
I can’t speak to the comparison between the two, but I can speak to the W as I am here now on day 3 of a 5 night stay on points. I booked the Fabulous OW villa and was upgraded to the Spectacular OW villa. (I am a lifetime platinum.). The Spectacular villa has a hammock and I believe it is often available on points.
The staff here is simply amazing and to a person, they love working here and it shows. Their attention to detail, smiles and desire to please the guest is truly something special. If you choose the W, I don’t think you will be disappointed.