Regarding (4), was deception involved if it's by AA's own mistake?
Regarding (5), so if AA upgrades you, it can come back afterwards and sue you saying "hey we upgraded you by accident and you are not entitled, so you have to pay us"? Note the word "intentionally" again.
Both of them having nothing to do with passively receiving.
Finally, it has nothing to do with ticket pricing. In the case where it's not scammed, AA has to prove that it lost money which it can't.
Last edited by fttc; Jul 28, 2019 at 9:52 pm