I swear I'm not delusional! I just went back and the fees are ~$30 for two people. I wish I had taken a screen shot. I had pulled up several options with BA and saw those fuel surcharges, which I was expecting, but then pulled up the QR flights and the charges were even higher.
Ok I think I see what's happening. I guess you can't hit the back button and select different flights? I had first selected BA, then clicked back and changed the date and selected a QR option. But it still shows the price for the BA option. I hadn't clicked all the way through to the "review and pay" screen where it would show me that I was still on the BA selection. My apologies for the false alarm!