Originally Posted by
stargold
A lot of SeatGuru comments are (i) generic, (ii) exaggerated, or (iii) downright incorrect. I believe you have encountered such a situation here.
The comments section is an odd one. Most posters review their flight as a whole, often mentioning service, food, or taking the opportunity to vent, even thought the name of the site is SEAT Guru and is meant to be all about SEATS. Some people post pictures and those can be helpful (the ones that include seats, that is... the food pix not so much.)
I got burned by SeatGuru once - took an AF flight in Y (an A340, IIRC) and the bulkhead was just terrible because it had no legroom; SeatGuru had that as a good seat.