I've booked a number of AA flights recently using reward redemption options - 12,500 mile and 7,500 mile variety. What I've noticed with AA is you need to book well in advance or take advantage of last minute award openings. I've flown my mother out from California at least three or four times in the past year to DCA or IAD or BWI and my cousin from SLC or SEA to DCA or BWI or IAD. Sometimes booked 24 hours before departure.
Don't expect holiday time flights for AA with a few exceptions though.