If I was already Gold or close enough that I could achieve it quickly with this Y policy, then I would take the position. Otherwise I would turn it down. Status makes SUCH a difference in LH travel, especially here in the US where AA flagship lounge (or here in LA, Qantas First lounge) access has been significantly improved.

Folks who ask you to take a reality check because your 2k Y only supplement payment is more than what others make annually is nonsense and they fail to appreciate that this 2k supplement is likely a small % increase in your salary and a reflection of your education, experience and expertise.

I would not count on AUP’s. Quite often my LAX-LHR-LAX AUP requests are denied. And if I have added a rental car (so becoming a BA holidays booking) my AUP rejection rate is 100%.

Good luck.