I stayed here once a few years ago. I wouldn't put it in the same league as the other hotels you reference but it was very nice. The room I had was pretty small (but proably normal for HK standards). The lounge breakfast was fine (maybe with make to order eggs?) but nothing spectacular. I seem to recall the lounge was small. Also the area was very quiet but not too far from a metro station and relatively easy to get to the HK Express. In short, nothing wrong with the hotel but it wasn't anything that wowed me either.