First, the choice depends on your preferences and what you're looking for - you haven't given enough information.
Small feel hotel like Andaz or large hotel with hundreds of rooms?
Super close and small beach access, or more of a pool person?
Kids age?
Activities preference (care about reefs, need kids diversions)?
Using a car to go all over Maui or neighborhood, or more a never leave the compound type? ..especially if one is going out to hit restaurants and town.
Then, as for Marriott, it's not in the class of those three... especially if there's still noisy construction going on at all hours.
Last, if your using money (vs. points), VRBO has some great options (again, depending on your style/preferences).