I think the only reason Carnival has a bad rep is that it is catered to the faimly/younger crowd. I guess I'm just not uptight enough to worry to much about other people (what they wear on the ship etc). I'm there to have a time, see some sights, eat great food, meet new people.

All my cruises have been on Carnival and I don't have any plans to use any other line in the foreseable future. The atmosphere is very laid back the food/ports are wonderful and its all at a very reasonable price.

I'd like to see the average age of person on different cruise lines.
I'd be willing to bet Carvnial is the youngest. For me its nice to be around people around our age.

Also I agree with you on the special $25 dining...it was worth the extra money!