Originally Posted by
3Cforme
I don't think a mix of business class seats across the fleet is a fatal flaw. AA, DL, and UA all have very large intercon fleets. What is space-efficient and offering a competitive set of amenities may not work across the full range 757-A359. Then there's the cycle of upgrades: a new seat can't be rolled out to ~120 aircraft instantly. DL has managed to offer lie-flats/aisle access on all long-haul widebodies. AA can't make that claim - it will be stuck installing last-gen seats even as Polaris and suites are rolling out.
AA's new SuperDiamond is not "last generation." It is BE Aerospace's improved version of the Zodiac Cirrus.
By comparison, Polaris is a modified version of Zodiac's SkyLounge. In Zodiac's product lineup, that seat is a lesser version of their Cirrus seat.