I am probably biased because I got married there last summer, but Calistoga is my favorite. Although if you stay there you will be a bit away from the action I think it is worth it. I also think anyone staying there needs to pay up for one of the lodges that has its own jacuzzi.having a lodge that does not share walls, like in a normal hotel building, is why we have always stayed there over Auberge.
David, is the Carneros Inn still a Virtuoso property?