Originally Posted by
echino
Yours worked probably because you already have cards in both product lines. But if you have, for example, only charge card, like Amex Gold, and then self-refer to Amex Aeroplan Gold, then you are likely not going to get the referral bonus, because you had not had a pre-existing Aeroplan card to deposit bonus to. At least that's what is reported in the Amex forum.
And what if I want to legitimately refer a friend to an Amex Aeroplan Gold and I only gave an Amex Gold MR? 1:1 conversion to MR perhaps? Maybe I should just ask Amex...