Originally Posted by
highlanderfil
I guess I was more looking for people's impressions of different islands since I haven't been there at all before. The logistics are important, but secondary - going cheaply to a destination we won't enjoy isn't exactly ideal
.
I mean, all three destinations offer beach, casinos, nightlife, golf, etc. You mentioned your preference towards all inclusive, I personally do not like them, as I feel that I'm missing out of something. With all inclusive you tend to spend time on the resort, all your food and drinks are included as some of the activities, there is no reason to venture outside. However, on the flip side, the advantage of all inclusive is that you do not spend time going out to eat, drink, if you do not know the area. Its give and take I guess.
SJU hotels are known for the "party" like atmosphere in the lobby, everyone dresses up and hangs out in the lobby bars.
SDQ is cheaper overall, your money will go longer.
SXM is my favorite, but it is expensive overall. You might also think on St Thomas, I enjoy it also.