I called, explained to them I love AMEX (and I do, own almost every card of theirs) and that I would like the difference.
Put on hold for 15 minutes, said she can't apply it until 6-8 weeks has passed since I spent $1,000, even though I already got the original 50k points. She noted my account and said to call back at the end of June and I will get the other 50k.
Strange how results are so different.