Cachugua General Store sounds insanely good. It's a shame we're not around Monday night, because I'd love to go. I couldn't find a proper website, but from their idiosyncratic blog:
A country store, hidden in the mountains 25 miles from the Carmel coast. Home of A Moveable Feast caterers, local organic foods since 1976..
Montrio sounds like a must.
I'll be looking up the others.
Keep the suggestions coming.