Originally Posted by
hhoope01
Realize the cost difference for the OP between the Marriott and the RC is only 10K points. Given that small a cost difference, I would always choose the RC over the Marriott. While the Marriott is nice and it sounds like the beach it is on is looking better, the RC is still a step up (maybe not 6 or 7 steps up though.)
Your point about the ability to purchase an all-inclusive option with points at the Marriott is a good one. While the all-inclusive add-on award has a sizeable point cost, it might be worth looking into (especially if there are only two of you.) That option can save quite a bit of money. Most of the nicer reestaurants on the island can be pricey. So if the OP has extra points, and values cash more, this is worth looking into. (But it is only an option while staying at the Marriott on an award. The RC doesn't have an all-inclusive option using points.)
The only other point I would add about the Marriott all inclusive package, you really only have one restaurant at the hotel to eat dinner. For four nights, we found it fine, however, if you were staying longer, you may get tired of it. All other service was fine as they give you a booklet at checkin outlining what is included in the package and not. Still pretty decent IMHO, will be using this packing again for four nights in April 2010.