I suffered through 2 years of ugly shooz with custom orthotics - the pledge was: "Wear these every day for 2 years and you will be pain free"
I did, and I have been pain free for about 8 years now --- I still do my ankle rolls and flexes every morning before getting out of bed. I just do NOT want to go through that again --- mostly because of the FUGLY shoes I had to wear.
I found all leather Naturalizers at Sears that held the orthotics nicely, and bought a black pair and an identical pair in navy... but they would have never made a 'cute' or 'pretty' list.