I have a couple rib roasts that I will be preparing for Christmas dinner. I have never cooked one before. There seem to be 3 different methods. One involves turning off the over after a specified time and leaving the thing in there to cook slooooowly. Another is an initial high temp and remaining hour at low temp. The third is steady low or medium roasting heat (the lower the temp, the longer the time). I consulted BV Jr#1 who has cooked a couple and he semi-failed at the first method since his oven vents through a back burner and he didn't know that beforehand. There was a last minute scramble to cook and heat the roast after everything else was ready.
I'm ready to try 30 minutes at 500, followed by 325 to finish, taking it out when the internal temp hits 120 degrees. But, never have I read so much conflicting information on a simple cut of meat. Baste or no baste, foil cover or no cover, steady heat or drop after 30-45 minutes. No one can even agree on how many servings. Can I hear anyone elses success stories? I hate the idea of ruining $60 worth of meat.
__________________
From C. Thompson's updated wisdom for the modern traveler: 1 Hang up on morons 2 Don't be that guy 3 Stop feeling so entitled
I tend to favour the middle method: High initial heat to sear and seal in the juices, then low heat for the rest of the cooking period, which you can also do by browning the meat on the stovetop. I'd cut the initial high heat period/temp down to either 500F for 10-15 minutes or 425F for 15-20 minutes, or put the joint in the oven at 450F and immediately turn down to 300F. Just be sure not to use non-stick pans and make sure your thermostat, if using one, can handle that temp. Put some water at the bottom of the pan so the juices don't burn (and make sure the liquids never dry out). No foil or cover. Basting always helps (and then you can check to see if the juices are drying out or not). If you can get a layer of fbeef at, put that over the top.
Slow cooking is said to favour tougher joints where you`re looking for the cartilage and tendons to melt with cooking at low heat (which is why pot roasting favours those).
__________________
"I have a fear of flying. I fear flying in the back cabin" My Flight Memory
well, i prefer making rib roast in the preheated oven to a temperature of 450°F and the roast should be placed on the rack in a roasting pan. whatever way you chose just check that it is properly cooked and dont forget to add two cups of wine is later added to the bottom of the pan for the purpose of forming a good quality of beef stock.
Programs: AA EXP, IC Plat RA...belong to most others but no status
Posts: 294
..and here's a vote for method #3!!
Cook's Illustrated/America's Test Kitchen turned me on to this method. It works great.
Your roast needs to be room temperature to start with; first sear it on the stovetop til well browned on all sides. Roast @ 250 degrees until it's at the right temp for your preference (122 for rare, 130+/- medium).
To prep you will need a spray bottle, garlic powder, black pepper and rosemary.
Spray roast with water and liberally cover with garlic powder. The idea here is to get a good crust on the roast. Spray again with water and cover with black pepper. Spray again with water and cover with rosemary. Put on much more than you think you would seem to need. It will seem like alot but the flavor throughout the roast is amazing.
Put in roasting pan on rack. 450 for 15 minutes. Be careful the top can easily burn at this temp so keep an eye on it. Drop down to 325 until internal temp is 120-125 depending on how you like it. Timing just depends on how big your roast is. The one I made on Sunday was 10 lbs and took about 1 1/2 hours.
Moderator: Flying Blue and Other European Frequent Flyer Programs
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: BCN - BD *G · Flying Dutchman RW
Posts: 7,514
The best I've ever had was done the Alton Brown way. He goes through the different methods and explains why, scientifically, one has better results than the others, along with dry aging. It's one of his better episodes (note you don't need the flower pot).
If you want a great rib roast, it's worth 22 minutes of your life to watch this episode.
Speaking of Alton, didn't he show on one episode that searing actually did nothing to seal in the juice? I seam to remember his searing one steak and not the other then baking the steaks and weighing them and there was pretty much no difference.
Anyway, I am on my way now to the store to pick up my roast. Small Christmas this year so probably only going with a 5-6 bone. I do the slow method and it comes out perfect every year. I give the roast 3-4 out of the fridge then cook 250 degrees and give it about 25-30 mins of rest time. I don't put a time on it, I cook to temp and tell the family it will be done when it's done. Also doing some baked asparagus with cheese and mashed potatoes. I'm taking it easy this year.
Programs: DL/NW Plat, BD *G, Hyatt Diam, Hertz 5*. Other programs: AA, CO, UA, Choice, HH, SPG, Club Cholula
Posts: 11,884
And no one's mentioned my favorite way to get the consistency I desire - a salt-crust roast. The only significant key is not too much water; the salt will leach into the roast that way. The kids would enjoy seeing dinner being made that involves a hammer at times ...
The best I've ever had was done the Alton Brown way.
If you want a great rib roast, it's worth 22 minutes of your life to watch this episode.
Second, third and fourth servings of this episode (and most Alton Brown stuff). Sometimes his prep methods are too OCD even for me, but I've had great success with every one of his recipes that I've tried.
Location: various cities in the USofA: NYC, BWI, IAH, CHI, ?
Programs: CO Gold, Hilton Gold somehow, AGR moocher via CO
Posts: 3,475
Quote:
Originally Posted by Owlchick
Second, third and fourth servings of this episode (and most Alton Brown stuff). Sometimes his prep methods are too OCD even for me, but I've had great success with every one of his recipes that I've tried.
Unlike pretty much every other cooking show host, Alton Brown generally explains why,not just how, he does things.
__________________ My Flights @ OpenFights(contains forward-looking statements and lacks historical accuracy).
Programs: British Air, Virgin, Alaska, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 92
Quote:
Originally Posted by icurhere2
And no one's mentioned my favorite way to get the consistency I desire - a salt-crust roast. The only significant key is not too much water; the salt will leach into the roast that way. The kids would enjoy seeing dinner being made that involves a hammer at times ...
I always do it this way--5 lbs of salt. The real key is to LET IT REST for a half hour once it's done.
