Probably a tie between chocolate chip cookie dough and cookies and cream ("boring" I know).. Though the Dublin Irish Creme, Vanilla Haeth Bar Crunch, Cake Batter, and Cinnamon Roll, all score very highly with me.
What I do find frustrating, is that many many great flavors are not widely available at all. I have been looking for the Mission to Mazipan for days but could not find a store that carries them. Same for Dublin Mudslides, Magic Brownies, etc. etc. This is in Manhattan and Brooklyn, and I have looked in four or five chains.
Kama Sutra seems to be the new flavor that every store carries nowadays, in addition to classical flavors.
If you can only carry two to three flavors, why settle for chocolate and vanilla?
What I do find frustrating, is that many many great flavors are not widely available at all. I have been looking for the Mission to Mazipan for days but could not find a store that carries them. Same for Dublin Mudslides, Magic Brownies, etc. etc. This is in Manhattan and Brooklyn, and I have looked in four or five chains.
Kama Sutra seems to be the new flavor that every store carries nowadays, in addition to classical flavors.
If you can only carry two to three flavors, why settle for chocolate and vanilla?
I found Mission to Marzipan at Walgreen's. Any options like that for you? Or will any store order if you request? ("did you find everything you were looking for...").