Last edit by: Canarsie
This discussion is unique on FlyerTalk in that it allows members who visit the Delta Air Lines SkyMiles forum to publicly comment on the decisions and actions of its moderators even though Rule 18 on FlyerTalk specifically prohibits doing this:
The moderators of the Delta Air Lines SkyMiles have learned a lot from your input through this discussion; and it has also served to resolve issues over the years often in a humorous manner.
Despite the existence of this discussion, the moderators of the Delta Air Lines SkyMiles still request that you first address any questions or concerns pertaining to the decisions and actions of the moderators via private communications before posting them publicly, as most issues can usually be resolved this way. Please use this discussion sparingly and only when necessary.
Thank you.
Regards,
Canarsie, obscure2k and ryandc99
Co-moderators, Delta Air Lines SkyMiles forum
Discussion Of Moderator Actions
Discussion Of Moderator Actions
Moderators value your private views and feedback related to their actions and duties. You may submit appropriate feedback to moderators by private message or e-mail. Do not post comments about moderator decisions or actions, or about the work of moderators, unless a moderator has invited members to post feedback in a particular thread.
Any concerns about the actions of a moderator should be directed exclusively and privately to the [email protected].
Any concerns about the actions of a moderator should be directed exclusively and privately to the [email protected].
Despite the existence of this discussion, the moderators of the Delta Air Lines SkyMiles still request that you first address any questions or concerns pertaining to the decisions and actions of the moderators via private communications before posting them publicly, as most issues can usually be resolved this way. Please use this discussion sparingly and only when necessary.
Thank you.
Regards,
Canarsie, obscure2k and ryandc99
Co-moderators, Delta Air Lines SkyMiles forum
Moderators Guilty of Premature Evacuation
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: MA
Programs: DL DM/2MM Marriott Platinum, HH Diamond,
Posts: 8,904
Moderators Guilty of Premature Evacuation
Bruce, you need some staying power. I asked some specific questions about the Shuttle 737-300, but you saved us all by shutting off the thread! Would you guys simply cool it? Haven't enough of us been clear about that?
#2
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Winter Garden, FL
Programs: Delta DM-3MM United Gold-MM Marriott Lifetime Titanium Hertz President's Circle
Posts: 13,498
But we already have a very good thread on the same subject, which I brought back to page 1. Why not keep all the information together? Isn't this much more useful to people?
Bruce
(Moderator)
Bruce
(Moderator)
#3
Original Poster
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: MA
Programs: DL DM/2MM Marriott Platinum, HH Diamond,
Posts: 8,904
<font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Originally posted by bdschobel:
But we already have a very good thread on the same subject, which I brought back to page 1. Why not keep all the information together? Isn't this much more useful to people?
Bruce
(Moderator)</font>
But we already have a very good thread on the same subject, which I brought back to page 1. Why not keep all the information together? Isn't this much more useful to people?
Bruce
(Moderator)</font>
Somebody made the analogy that the role of the police in Greenwich CT is different than the role of the police in the Bronx. I thought that was a wonderful analogy. The moderators keep promising to be restrained, but it ain't happening, IMO. If there are multiple threads on the same topic, some will live and some will not. That is the way it has been here in "Greenwich" for the several years that I have been here without moderator intervention and guidance.
#4
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: SEA - DL DM/2MM, *A Gold, SPG Lifetime Plat, some other car and hotel stuff
Posts: 5,649
Amen.
edited to add:
When the moderators close another thread, and someone starts a new thread to protest the closure, will the protest thread be shut down and all protesters pointed in the direction of THIS thread?
Just something to chew on.
Also edited to add: LOVE the thread title.
[This message has been edited by andymo99 (edited 02-11-2003).]
edited to add:
When the moderators close another thread, and someone starts a new thread to protest the closure, will the protest thread be shut down and all protesters pointed in the direction of THIS thread?
Just something to chew on.
Also edited to add: LOVE the thread title.
[This message has been edited by andymo99 (edited 02-11-2003).]
#5
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Winter Garden, FL
Programs: Delta DM-3MM United Gold-MM Marriott Lifetime Titanium Hertz President's Circle
Posts: 13,498
On January 31, I posted my experience on the same type of plane to the other thread. The closed thread was merely starting the same discussion all over again. The fundamental purpose of FT is to share information, and users are not well served by having to dig through multiple threads with similar postings. It just wastes everybody's time.
The reason that I jumped in and closed the other thread immediately is that I am reluctant to close them after they have a lot of postings. It's better to stop them early and redirect the discussion to the earlier thread, as I did.
I'm sorry that your post got through in the 15 seconds or so between my post announcing the closing and the actual closing. I had no way of knowing that you were posting just as I was closing the thread. No slight was intended, as I'm sure you realize.
Nobody is trying to engage in heavy-handed moderating. I'm just trying to stop the information exchange from being unnecessarily chaotic. Having said that, if other people believe that I'm doing more harm than good, please say so, either right here or through private e-mail. My goal is to be helpful, and if I'm not accomplishing that goal, someone needs to tell me!
Bruce
The reason that I jumped in and closed the other thread immediately is that I am reluctant to close them after they have a lot of postings. It's better to stop them early and redirect the discussion to the earlier thread, as I did.
I'm sorry that your post got through in the 15 seconds or so between my post announcing the closing and the actual closing. I had no way of knowing that you were posting just as I was closing the thread. No slight was intended, as I'm sure you realize.
Nobody is trying to engage in heavy-handed moderating. I'm just trying to stop the information exchange from being unnecessarily chaotic. Having said that, if other people believe that I'm doing more harm than good, please say so, either right here or through private e-mail. My goal is to be helpful, and if I'm not accomplishing that goal, someone needs to tell me!
Bruce
#6
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Exile
Posts: 15,630
Of course this same standard of "chaotic information" does not hold when certain users (and even certain moderators) continue to spam the forums with the same threads about billboards et al..
Go figure
Go figure
#7
Original Poster
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: MA
Programs: DL DM/2MM Marriott Platinum, HH Diamond,
Posts: 8,904
<font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Originally posted by andymo99:
Also edited to add: LOVE the thread title.
[This message has been edited by andymo99 (edited 02-11-2003).]</font>
Also edited to add: LOVE the thread title.
[This message has been edited by andymo99 (edited 02-11-2003).]</font>
#8
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: ATL
Programs: DL GM, UA PE, National EE, Priority Club Plat, SPG Gold, AMEX Plat
Posts: 264
Flyertalk isn't fun anymore....
#9
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Winter Garden, FL
Programs: Delta DM-3MM United Gold-MM Marriott Lifetime Titanium Hertz President's Circle
Posts: 13,498
Actually, we're trying to minimize the number of threads on those subjects, too. The four moderators have exchanged e-mails on that subject.
The basic problem, as I described above, is that we don't want to close threads AFTER they have grown large. If we close them early and redirect the discussion to an existing thread, we have done something good (in my opinion, anyway). If we close them too late, we are just isolating a packet of information that will disappear eventually into old-age oblivion. That's not good.
Bruce
The basic problem, as I described above, is that we don't want to close threads AFTER they have grown large. If we close them early and redirect the discussion to an existing thread, we have done something good (in my opinion, anyway). If we close them too late, we are just isolating a packet of information that will disappear eventually into old-age oblivion. That's not good.
Bruce
#10
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: NYC
Programs: AA EXP / LT PLT / 3MM, Marriott LT Gold
Posts: 35,278
Bruce, with all due respect, I must side with RobertS975 and andymo99 on this issue. Without getting into the specific merits of this particular action, I do believe that less is more when it comes to moderating. Recently, quite a few threads have been closed just when I thought they were getting interesting! So what if they were straying into territory that had only a tenuous connection with DL?
I'm also finding myself in rare agreement with a post on this board by B747-437B. While I am as disconcerted with the SM changes as anyone else, I think we have made ourselves look like whiners with the proliferation of huge me-too threads that say nothing new.
Just my $0.02 ...
------------------
Vasant
I'm also finding myself in rare agreement with a post on this board by B747-437B. While I am as disconcerted with the SM changes as anyone else, I think we have made ourselves look like whiners with the proliferation of huge me-too threads that say nothing new.
Just my $0.02 ...
------------------
Vasant
#11
Moderator: Delta SkyMiles, Luxury Hotels, TravelBuzz! and Italy
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Los Angeles
Posts: 26,502
Quote:
Just my $0.02 ...
--Your two cents are highly valued--
Just my $0.02 ...
--Your two cents are highly valued--
#12
Join Date: Oct 2000
Location: SEA, or BOS, or MUC, or other places (probably connecting). "Detroit, Michigan is in the Eastern time zone."
Programs: DL PM/1MM, AS 100K, NEXUS/GE, CLEAR, Bonvoy Platinum, Hilton Gold
Posts: 1,201
A thought...if the "older" thread has already aged off of page 1, then it's less important to merge/kill threads to keep from crowding other topics off of the first page.
In this case, by bringing the older one back, the situation was actually made worse, since we now have a closed thread hanging on to a front-page slot until it gets pushed off to ATL concourse D, er, page 2.
(Plus this thread, which is taking up yet another page 1 gate desperately needed for a Song Air arrival... )
In this case, by bringing the older one back, the situation was actually made worse, since we now have a closed thread hanging on to a front-page slot until it gets pushed off to ATL concourse D, er, page 2.
(Plus this thread, which is taking up yet another page 1 gate desperately needed for a Song Air arrival... )
#13
Moderator: Hilton Honors forums
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Marietta, Georgia, United States
Posts: 24,977
In keeping with the topic "Moderators Guilty of Premature Evacuation"...
I believe as long as someone is not being a jerk-off about it, a thread should be allowed to live, reach its climax in popularity, and be allowed to go limp of its own volition. However, the condomnation of the moderators is also not necessary. They are trying to do the best job they can without being messy about it. So the conception of a few ancillary threads squirt by. So what? No big deal. There is no need to be a pill about it. Let us sponge up the information as necessary if it is pertinent, and not erect animosity in this esteemed foreplay ... er ... I mean forum. In other words, let's continue master debating the issues.
Who says FlyerTalk isn't fun anymore...?
Oh, yeah ... PMD did.
I believe as long as someone is not being a jerk-off about it, a thread should be allowed to live, reach its climax in popularity, and be allowed to go limp of its own volition. However, the condomnation of the moderators is also not necessary. They are trying to do the best job they can without being messy about it. So the conception of a few ancillary threads squirt by. So what? No big deal. There is no need to be a pill about it. Let us sponge up the information as necessary if it is pertinent, and not erect animosity in this esteemed foreplay ... er ... I mean forum. In other words, let's continue master debating the issues.
Who says FlyerTalk isn't fun anymore...?
Oh, yeah ... PMD did.
#14
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: NYC
Programs: AA EXP / LT PLT / 3MM, Marriott LT Gold
Posts: 35,278
Canarsie, do you have a day job?
------------------
Vasant
------------------
Vasant
#15
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Buckhead (upgraded from Dunwoody)
Posts: 370
I bet jimpop is rolling around laughing at you guys. It seems to me you are more upset with moderators than with not.
My $.02 is that the moderators need moderating.
My $.02 is that the moderators need moderating.