Open Jaw (kind of) is Cheaper Than Round Trip or Two One-Ways
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Formerly at PIT, now planted near MSP.
Programs: No flights since April 2019 (Medical Issues). Lost all my status.
Posts: 1,483
Open Jaw (kind of) is Cheaper Than Round Trip or Two One-Ways
Has anyone else done this....
* I need to fly PIT-MSP- PIT with an 8 day stay in MSP.
* DL wants $400+ for a round trip, even more for two one-ways.
* Flying PIT-DTW-ORD (DL), ORD-MSP (UA) and MSP-PIT costs $250 (DL) + $50 (UA).
* I need to fly PIT-MSP- PIT with an 8 day stay in MSP.
* DL wants $400+ for a round trip, even more for two one-ways.
* Flying PIT-DTW-ORD (DL), ORD-MSP (UA) and MSP-PIT costs $250 (DL) + $50 (UA).
#3
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jun 2015
Location: Back in Reds Country (DAY/CVG). Previously: SEA & SAT.
Programs: DL PM 1MM, AA PLAT, UA Silver, Marriott Bonvoy Titanium
Posts: 10,346
All to save $100? I wouldn't risk the connection in ORD to another airline which will have no obligation to rebook you if you misconnect. You'd be out far more than $100 if that happens.
If you're looking at double connections and don't care about time, have you also looked at driving to another airport such as CLE-MSP? CAK-MSP? Or even CMH?
ETA: What does DL want on ORD-MSP? If it's not that much more than UA you could do that and at least be entirely protected if all legs/tickets are on DL.
If you're looking at double connections and don't care about time, have you also looked at driving to another airport such as CLE-MSP? CAK-MSP? Or even CMH?
ETA: What does DL want on ORD-MSP? If it's not that much more than UA you could do that and at least be entirely protected if all legs/tickets are on DL.
#5
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Minneapolis: DL DM charter 2.3MM
Programs: A3*Gold, SPG Plat, HyattDiamond, MarriottPP, LHW exAccess, ICI, Raffles Amb, NW PE MM, TWA Gold MM
Posts: 100,399
DL is often cheap between MSP and ORD (or DTW and ORD) for either OW or RT. I'd be willing to pay a bit more to have all segments on DL.
OTOH, OP doesn't seem to be striving for status on DL or any other carrier, so especially if this is business travel, I'd suggest just taking the nonstop RT for $400, which IME is a good price for MSP.
You might experiment with fares for something like PIT-MSP-MDW (throw away the final segment) purchased as a OW ticket and a separate OW ticket for MSP-PIT. This assumes that you do NOT check luggage on the outbound.
OTOH, OP doesn't seem to be striving for status on DL or any other carrier, so especially if this is business travel, I'd suggest just taking the nonstop RT for $400, which IME is a good price for MSP.
You might experiment with fares for something like PIT-MSP-MDW (throw away the final segment) purchased as a OW ticket and a separate OW ticket for MSP-PIT. This assumes that you do NOT check luggage on the outbound.
#6
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: BDU
Programs: DL:MM, Marriott:LTT
Posts: 8,779
I do this frequently for international flights where the savings can be in the thousands. Often it is much less expensive to fly to Asia or even Europe starting in JFK or LAX and adding on the r/t to/fr ATL as a second ticket. You are taking chances - late flights can be on you - when you do this and you will have to point out the second ticket at both check-ins to have your bags routed correctly, as the agent will only see the first flight without extra data entry. It's never been an issue, even when I've flown from JFK and back to LAX, with separate flight to/fr ATL tacked on.
Is it worth $100? Probably not. Is it worth $1k? Yes.
Is it worth $100? Probably not. Is it worth $1k? Yes.
#7
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Minneapolis: DL DM charter 2.3MM
Programs: A3*Gold, SPG Plat, HyattDiamond, MarriottPP, LHW exAccess, ICI, Raffles Amb, NW PE MM, TWA Gold MM
Posts: 100,399
If you're saving a thousand dollars and have the time, you can arrange an overnight between the two tickets to minimize the risk, especially on the outbound. This can be especially handy if you need a couple hotel stays to requalify for status and there are decent and relatively cheap airport hotels for your chain. In fact, sometimes the overnight stop is relaxing/fun versus taking a very early flight the next day, although it can be a bit of a pain to go between the airport and hotel with luggage, depending on the particulars.
IMO from this perspective, LAX is better than NYC (assuming you don't have enough time to go into the city for a couple nights along the way) but even on a single ticket, I'll sometimes overnight at the DTW Westin to avoid a tight connection from a very early flight.
IMO from this perspective, LAX is better than NYC (assuming you don't have enough time to go into the city for a couple nights along the way) but even on a single ticket, I'll sometimes overnight at the DTW Westin to avoid a tight connection from a very early flight.
Last edited by MSPeconomist; Aug 22, 2017 at 10:38 pm
#8
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: BDU
Programs: DL:MM, Marriott:LTT
Posts: 8,779
IMO from this perspective, LAX is better than NYC (assuming you don't have enough time to go into the city for a couple nights along the way) but even on a single ticket, I'll sometimes overnight at the DTW Westin to avoid a tight connection from a very early flight.
#9
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Minneapolis: DL DM charter 2.3MM
Programs: A3*Gold, SPG Plat, HyattDiamond, MarriottPP, LHW exAccess, ICI, Raffles Amb, NW PE MM, TWA Gold MM
Posts: 100,399
Going out, I'm aways able to get a four hour or so layover, which has always proven enough time. Or I purposely overnight in LAX to visit family. Coming back, I try to do early morning into JFK and late night out and am usually able to SDC to an earlier flight. Recently I had to do eight hours or so overnight at JFK and just slept in the airport. Hotels are too expensive near the airport and horrible for what you pay for. My cousin lives near LAX so if I cannot get a good hotel rate near the airport I can stay with her, so it does work out better for me. Usually, though, the LAX Ren or Marriott had a decent rate. DTW never has good rates for when/where I want to fly.
#11
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Minneapolis: DL DM charter 2.3MM
Programs: A3*Gold, SPG Plat, HyattDiamond, MarriottPP, LHW exAccess, ICI, Raffles Amb, NW PE MM, TWA Gold MM
Posts: 100,399
Is OP's primary goal to make the trip when scheduled, to save money, or to earn MQMs/MQSs? It would help to understand the objective here. Also, does the OP have spare time to devote to this endeavor, for instance spending most of the day making a trip by air of well under a thousand miles?
#12
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 23,045
To top it off, OP's proposed routing/prices appears to be Basic Economy fares (the cheapest non-BE fare I can find for PIT-ORD/MSP-PIT on DL is a $265 V fare), while the $400 non-stop option is not (U fare outbound, X fare return). Would have been nice to mention that.
OP, the U/X/V fares on PIT-MSP have a roundtrip and Saturday night stay requirement, so you can't purchase them separately as one-way's. The cheapest one-way fare you can purchase is an L fare ($263.20 one-way). This can all be found in the fare rules. This is typical where a legacy does not face LCC non-stop competition (WN does not fly PIT-MSP non-stop). Your cheaper fare is due to a WN fare sale and DL is fare matching WN's PIT-MDW prices on PIT-ORD/MDW, and UA is fare matching WN MDW-MSP prices on ORD-MSP. FYI, the WN sale ends today.
OP, the U/X/V fares on PIT-MSP have a roundtrip and Saturday night stay requirement, so you can't purchase them separately as one-way's. The cheapest one-way fare you can purchase is an L fare ($263.20 one-way). This can all be found in the fare rules. This is typical where a legacy does not face LCC non-stop competition (WN does not fly PIT-MSP non-stop). Your cheaper fare is due to a WN fare sale and DL is fare matching WN's PIT-MDW prices on PIT-ORD/MDW, and UA is fare matching WN MDW-MSP prices on ORD-MSP. FYI, the WN sale ends today.
#13
Join Date: Oct 2005
Programs: DL 2MM PM;VSGld;EKGld; HilDia; HrtzPC; AvisPC; PP; AmbPlt; JumeiGld; MeliaPlt; TajPlt; ShangriDia
Posts: 953
In this instance, it really seems the lower price is the fact that you are traveling to/from MSP on a UA fare which may be less than DL, because MSP is non-hub airport for UA. If you want to save the $100, I would simply dump the PIT-DTW-ORD flight portion on DL and fly round trip on UA where you could net a PIT-IAD-MSP or a PIT-ORD-MSP roundtrip for the same $250 price.
In instances where I have split carriers to obtain a lower fare, I generally would not even consider staying loyal to DL unless I could fly at least one-way to my destination on Delta. In this case, you are proposing splitting carriers to net two short segments on DL. At that point, I'd just fly UA on a convenient itinerary if the $400 price point is more than you want to pay on DL.
In instances where I have split carriers to obtain a lower fare, I generally would not even consider staying loyal to DL unless I could fly at least one-way to my destination on Delta. In this case, you are proposing splitting carriers to net two short segments on DL. At that point, I'd just fly UA on a convenient itinerary if the $400 price point is more than you want to pay on DL.
#14
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 23,045
In this instance, it really seems the lower price is the fact that you are traveling to/from MSP on a UA fare which may be less than DL, because MSP is non-hub airport for UA. If you want to save the $100, I would simply dump the PIT-DTW-ORD flight portion on DL and fly round trip on UA where you could net a PIT-IAD-MSP or a PIT-ORD-MSP roundtrip for the same $250 price.
In instances where I have split carriers to obtain a lower fare, I generally would not even consider staying loyal to DL unless I could fly at least one-way to my destination on Delta. In this case, you are proposing splitting carriers to net two short segments on DL. At that point, I'd just fly UA on a convenient itinerary if the $400 price point is more than you want to pay on DL.
In instances where I have split carriers to obtain a lower fare, I generally would not even consider staying loyal to DL unless I could fly at least one-way to my destination on Delta. In this case, you are proposing splitting carriers to net two short segments on DL. At that point, I'd just fly UA on a convenient itinerary if the $400 price point is more than you want to pay on DL.
#15
Original Poster
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Formerly at PIT, now planted near MSP.
Programs: No flights since April 2019 (Medical Issues). Lost all my status.
Posts: 1,483
OP here....
Thank you for your thoughts. Here are a few more points ...
* The Basic Economy seats don't bother me, at least for short flights. I use them all the time.
* I'm paying for this trip.
* I need a few more segments to make GM, thus the extra legs don't bother me.
* I can do my job just as easily on an airplane or at an airport gate as I can do it in the office. I'm lucky in that I have only a minimum commitment to be in the office.
* My flexibility gives me opportunties for bumps and flight delay (or cancelation) changes that can work to my advantage.
Thank you for your thoughts. Here are a few more points ...
* The Basic Economy seats don't bother me, at least for short flights. I use them all the time.
* I'm paying for this trip.
* I need a few more segments to make GM, thus the extra legs don't bother me.
* I can do my job just as easily on an airplane or at an airport gate as I can do it in the office. I'm lucky in that I have only a minimum commitment to be in the office.
* My flexibility gives me opportunties for bumps and flight delay (or cancelation) changes that can work to my advantage.