What's With Checking IDs at Federal Court But Not Comparing to a List?
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Jul 2000
Posts: 3,746
What's With Checking IDs at Federal Court But Not Comparing to a List?
I'm not looking for the usual answers like "because they are idiots."
I've gone to the Bankruptcy Court a number of times over the years (as an attorney.) The US Marshals at the metal detectors always ask to see ID, but never check it against a blacklist.
The obvious TSA rationale for asking for ID is that they check it against a list to make sure you are not a threat (yes, I know the list sucks.)
But, what is the possible rationale for checking ID, but not checking it against a list?
I've gone to the Bankruptcy Court a number of times over the years (as an attorney.) The US Marshals at the metal detectors always ask to see ID, but never check it against a blacklist.
The obvious TSA rationale for asking for ID is that they check it against a list to make sure you are not a threat (yes, I know the list sucks.)
But, what is the possible rationale for checking ID, but not checking it against a list?
#2
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: BOS and vicinity
Programs: Former UA 1P
Posts: 3,723
Checking a blacklist can actually serve a purpose. Requiring a specific ID, e.g., a military ID, to get into a facility serves a purpose of restricting access. But *any* ID check that both does not include a blacklist and will accept any arbitrary government (or non government) photo ID is theater.
Note that the government is to some extent attempting to make possession of a valid photo ID a "privilege" that they can take away. The only reason for an ID to expire is to give the government an option to not renew it at some point in the future. Makes sense for a driver's license (you could go blind), but not for general IDs that are effectively required to travel or engage in commerce.
#4
Moderator: Manufactured Spending
Join Date: Jul 2011
Posts: 6,578
I'm not looking for the usual answers like "because they are idiots."
I've gone to the Bankruptcy Court a number of times over the years (as an attorney.) The US Marshals at the metal detectors always ask to see ID, but never check it against a blacklist.
The obvious TSA rationale for asking for ID is that they check it against a list to make sure you are not a threat (yes, I know the list sucks.)
But, what is the possible rationale for checking ID, but not checking it against a list?
I've gone to the Bankruptcy Court a number of times over the years (as an attorney.) The US Marshals at the metal detectors always ask to see ID, but never check it against a blacklist.
The obvious TSA rationale for asking for ID is that they check it against a list to make sure you are not a threat (yes, I know the list sucks.)
But, what is the possible rationale for checking ID, but not checking it against a list?
#5
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: BOS
Posts: 63
I run into the same thing at some military bases. If they happen to be running 100% ID checks, then they ask me for an ID. Two weeks ago, I showed my passport card which would at least prove US citizenship. They didn't know what to make of it, so they asked for a drivers license (I wasn't the driver of the car). Some bases scan and capture the ID bar code which would at least keep a record of who came on base. That I understand. Most just look at the ID and hand it back to me. Proved nothing.
#6
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Under the Cone of Silence
Programs: UA Gold; AA Dirt; HH Diamond; National Emerald; CONTROL SecretAgent Platinum; KAOS EvilFlyer Gold
Posts: 1,498
Ran into this at, of all things, my wife's naturalization ceremony.
Guards were requiring everyone to show ID to enter the courthouse, but were not checking it against anything. Family members of people being naturalized were being turned away until they went and got some form of ID to show.
Ultimately, I don't think anyone who wanted to attend the ceremony didn't get in, but I can just imagine the disgusting specter of someone being barred from being able to attend a citizenship swearing-in ceremony over something like this.
Guards were requiring everyone to show ID to enter the courthouse, but were not checking it against anything. Family members of people being naturalized were being turned away until they went and got some form of ID to show.
Ultimately, I don't think anyone who wanted to attend the ceremony didn't get in, but I can just imagine the disgusting specter of someone being barred from being able to attend a citizenship swearing-in ceremony over something like this.
#7
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 1,972
No. And any requirement that people can only enter some location if they have ID is a prima facia violation of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 because studies have shown that twice as many blacks don't have ID as whites, so the effect of such a rule disproportionately discriminates against blacks.
#8
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: HEL
Programs: lots of shiny metal cards
Posts: 14,103
No. And any requirement that people can only enter some location if they have ID is a prima facia violation of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 because studies have shown that twice as many blacks don't have ID as whites, so the effect of such a rule disproportionately discriminates against blacks.
#9
Suspended
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: DCA
Programs: UA US CO AA DL FL
Posts: 50,262
In many parts of the country, it's common for private building security to require ID as well. But, as with almost all Federal (and state facilities), the security / law enforcement don't check the name against anything in particular.
While I don't subscribe to it, there is a theory that people who have identified themselves are less likely to do bad things than people who have not.
At some Federal facilities it can be worse than TSA checkpoints at airports because there's no backup plan if you don't have ID with you. In other words, no ID = no entry. Period.
While I don't subscribe to it, there is a theory that people who have identified themselves are less likely to do bad things than people who have not.
At some Federal facilities it can be worse than TSA checkpoints at airports because there's no backup plan if you don't have ID with you. In other words, no ID = no entry. Period.
#10
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Salish Sea
Programs: DL,AC,HH,PC
Posts: 8,974
The TSA does not check passengers' names against any list; that is done at check-in by the airline. All the TSA does is verify() that the ID and BP match; decide for yourselves how that charade "enhances" security.
#11
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: The Sunshine State
Programs: Deltaworst Peon Level, TSA "Layer 21 Club", NW WP RIP
Posts: 11,370
#13
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 3,657
But this is purely speculative on my part.