Whole Body Scanners Opt Out Stories [merged]
#1892
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Houston, Texas
Posts: 959
This happened to me recently, and I didn't offer my hand. (I've counted 34 patdowns so far). I asked the TSO if I was done. He said "have a nice flight". I responded with "F U - pervert" and walked away. I'm sure I made his day much more pleasant. BTW - don't try this until you're sure that they are finished.
#1893
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Salish Sea
Programs: DL,AC,HH,PC
Posts: 8,974
I was pointing out that your observation of few opt-outs is by no means unusual.
#1895
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: Pacific Northwest
Posts: 118
"History will not look back kindly on you and what you're doing here."
#1896
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: LAX
Programs: AA EXP, HHonors Diamond
Posts: 102
Opted out at JFK T8 last week. Backscatter machines were being used with all WTMDs roped off despite lines being 8 or 9 people deep waiting for the scanner. A man in front of me opted out and was taken around the WTMD (not through it) for his pat down.
When I told the TSO I was opting out he told me to wait in front of the WTMD. I replied that I couldn't see my things on the x-ray belt, to which he said "there's nothing I can do." When I stated that TSA policy says I need to see my belongings, he called over the TSO running the backscatter machine saying "we have a problem." Just as I'm ready to ask for someone with stripes on their shoulders, my groper arrived and I was taken around the WTMD (not through it).
The pat down was brief. No karate chops, crotch touching, or fingers in the hair. Not even a ETD swab. When I asked for new gloves, the TSO responded "of course, I keep a whole bunch in my pocket." I then explain how cross contamination works and ask if there are a lot of false positives on ETD swabs. The response "yeah, almost all of them and the rest of them are heart medication or have been gardening." Total time from the TDC to clearing the checkpoint was maybe 10 minutes.
I'll be writing to all my elected officials.
When I told the TSO I was opting out he told me to wait in front of the WTMD. I replied that I couldn't see my things on the x-ray belt, to which he said "there's nothing I can do." When I stated that TSA policy says I need to see my belongings, he called over the TSO running the backscatter machine saying "we have a problem." Just as I'm ready to ask for someone with stripes on their shoulders, my groper arrived and I was taken around the WTMD (not through it).
The pat down was brief. No karate chops, crotch touching, or fingers in the hair. Not even a ETD swab. When I asked for new gloves, the TSO responded "of course, I keep a whole bunch in my pocket." I then explain how cross contamination works and ask if there are a lot of false positives on ETD swabs. The response "yeah, almost all of them and the rest of them are heart medication or have been gardening." Total time from the TDC to clearing the checkpoint was maybe 10 minutes.
I'll be writing to all my elected officials.
#1897
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Nashville, TN
Programs: WN Nothing and spending the half million points from too many flights, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 8,043
Today, BUF, early in the morning, about 5:30. There are about a gazillion kids in the airport with matching bag tags generally standing around in non-moving groups waiting for something but going nowhere. This made for a good start.
Used the premium line, got past the TDC quickly using NEXUS (it was BUF) and was directed to the Backscatter machines. Oops, not today. "I opt out." Then it got strange.
Oh, they let me watch my stuff. Until they moved some of it away and left some of it. I said that that, and also that over there is mine, can we do this where I can watch all of it? Sure, and we did.
I had three friskers and a bag swabber. I get my money's worth.
There was a non-uniform guy that was the traffic director. He got everything started and then left. I was frisked by a guy in a white shirt with no markings. He was supervised by a person of one stripe.
I stopped them both and told them that I was hearing impaired. Whatever they said may be misunderstood. So I gave them their speech for them and asked the to nod if it was correct. Both did. Then white shirt started by going through the speech. I looked at one stripe, "Are we training today?" He nodded.
The frisk was the oddest ever. The guy had been through the training but was clumsy and did some things twice like he maybe forgot. He was nice, and was not rough. It was like he really did not need the extra complication, me not hearing and telling him how to do his job, but he was not angry, just baffled. It was over quick enough. No privates touched. Not even close.
All the while, the original non-uniform was watching intently, but at a distance. I guess the trainer was being trained doing training.
White shirt held out his gloved hands and the trainer swabbed them hard and thoroughly. I still say that the primary purpose of the all over rub is ETD samples and not lumps under the clothes.
All said and done, I asked for the training discount as I left and they both chuckled.
Yeah, real funny.
Pretty darn serious work to leave to two trainees with only perfunctory supervision. At least to hear them tell it.
Used the premium line, got past the TDC quickly using NEXUS (it was BUF) and was directed to the Backscatter machines. Oops, not today. "I opt out." Then it got strange.
Oh, they let me watch my stuff. Until they moved some of it away and left some of it. I said that that, and also that over there is mine, can we do this where I can watch all of it? Sure, and we did.
I had three friskers and a bag swabber. I get my money's worth.
There was a non-uniform guy that was the traffic director. He got everything started and then left. I was frisked by a guy in a white shirt with no markings. He was supervised by a person of one stripe.
I stopped them both and told them that I was hearing impaired. Whatever they said may be misunderstood. So I gave them their speech for them and asked the to nod if it was correct. Both did. Then white shirt started by going through the speech. I looked at one stripe, "Are we training today?" He nodded.
The frisk was the oddest ever. The guy had been through the training but was clumsy and did some things twice like he maybe forgot. He was nice, and was not rough. It was like he really did not need the extra complication, me not hearing and telling him how to do his job, but he was not angry, just baffled. It was over quick enough. No privates touched. Not even close.
All the while, the original non-uniform was watching intently, but at a distance. I guess the trainer was being trained doing training.
White shirt held out his gloved hands and the trainer swabbed them hard and thoroughly. I still say that the primary purpose of the all over rub is ETD samples and not lumps under the clothes.
All said and done, I asked for the training discount as I left and they both chuckled.
Yeah, real funny.
Pretty darn serious work to leave to two trainees with only perfunctory supervision. At least to hear them tell it.
#1898
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Between AUS, EWR, and YTO In a little twisty maze of airline seats, all alike.. but I wanna go home with the armadillo
Programs: CO, NW, & UA forum moderator emeritus
Posts: 35,385
I opted-out at EWR-A3 the other day. As I got to the WTMD, they were opening up the MMW. A woman dodged in front of me to get to the WTMD first so I was sent to the MMW. I told them I refused to be scanned by the MMW machine. They made me remove my belt saying it had to be x-rayed. Then they insisted that I not walk through the WTMD, and instead opened a pass-through gate. I then had a rather normal (not particularly intrusive) patdown. I've opted out quite a few times. I have never had them insist that I remove my belt or that I not walk thrugh the WTMD before.
Last edited by Xyzzy; Nov 11, 2011 at 2:21 pm
#1899
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: SEA/YVR/BLI
Programs: UA "Lifetime" Gold, AS MVPG100K, OW Emerald, HH Lifetime Diamond, IC Plat, Marriott Gold, Hertz Gold
Posts: 9,488
I opted-out at EWR-A3 the other day. As I got to the WTMD, they were opening up the MMW. A woman dodged in front of me to get to the WTMD first so I was sent to the MMW. I told them I refused to be scanned by the MMW machine. They made me remove my belt saying it had to be x-rayed. Then they insisted that I not walk through the WTMD, and instead opened a pass-through gate. I then had a rather normal (not particularly intrusive) patdown. I've opted out quite a few times. I have never had them insist that I remove my belt or not walk thrugh the WTMD before.
It's also odd that you can't take a shortcut through the WTMD. It is it because your not setting it off would be embarrassing?
Agreed that it's all strange.
#1900
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Nashville, TN
Programs: WN Nothing and spending the half million points from too many flights, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 8,043
I opted-out at EWR-A3 the other day. As I got to the WTMD, they were opening up the MMW. A woman dodged in front of me to get to the WTMD first so I was sent to the MMW. I told them I refused to be scanned by the MMW machine. They made me remove my belt saying it had to be x-rayed. Then they insisted that I not walk through the WTMD, and instead opened a pass-through gate. I then had a rather normal (not particularly intrusive) patdown. I've opted out quite a few times. I have never had them insist that I remove my belt or that I not walk thrugh the WTMD before.
Also, I have a wad-up-able jacket. Wallet, watch, cellphone all go in the jacket. Jacket is rolled up and stuffed in the big pocket of my backpack. Belt goes on top of jacket. Cable ties on double zipper. All done long before I get to the TDC. While I get the inevitable swab of the carry on, I put on my belt, pull out the jacket and put it on transferring my stuff out of the jacket to their proper locations. It is a system that works for me.
#1901
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Between EWR & PHL
Programs: UA MileagePlus dirt (former hard-way Silver); AS Mileage Plan MVP; Hilton Honors Silver
Posts: 1,586
I assume your belt doesn't contain metal. I always remove mine because it does. What about drawstrings on sweat pants? What about a cummerbund or a toupee? I'm sure the answers are all in the fine print somewhere.
It's also odd that you can't take a shortcut through the WTMD. It is it because your not setting it off would be embarrassing?
Agreed that it's all strange.
It's also odd that you can't take a shortcut through the WTMD. It is it because your not setting it off would be embarrassing?
Agreed that it's all strange.
#1902
Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 67
Flew through Seattle the other day. Rude SOB at the front, "Do you actually understand how these machines work?" as if I was an idiot. Asked if I consented to a search. I replied as long as it didn't touch my genitals. He read from a card that included "We will not purposefully touch your genital area." Note the word purposefully. Had a little ollllllllddddd Asian do the pat down. Very thorough and conscientious. Talked me up more than felt me up. Noticed that most of the gropers were now small and old - I suppose that's less threatening (certainly better than the previous demographic that was at SEA). Very encouraged to see that the pat-down lines were FULL and being used consistently. Maybe people ARE waking up.
We'll use LaGuardia instead of JFK or Long Island from now on. No naked scanners. Instead, there are the usual metal detectors, a LOT of TSA personnel, and random checks. As soon as a booth is open, someone is randomly selected. They're inside the booth for about 4 minutes; I noticed at least three agents studying me while in there. Then those randomly selected are selected again for either swab, wand, or full patdown. What I observed was that elderly were wanded, women were swabbed, and men were selected for the full monty. It was very fast, and I thought very secure. LGA has apparently joined the ranks of those airports deciding that well-trained agents are a much better shield than numbskulls who can't get a job anywhere else, but who rely on technology that can be skirted.
We'll use LaGuardia instead of JFK or Long Island from now on. No naked scanners. Instead, there are the usual metal detectors, a LOT of TSA personnel, and random checks. As soon as a booth is open, someone is randomly selected. They're inside the booth for about 4 minutes; I noticed at least three agents studying me while in there. Then those randomly selected are selected again for either swab, wand, or full patdown. What I observed was that elderly were wanded, women were swabbed, and men were selected for the full monty. It was very fast, and I thought very secure. LGA has apparently joined the ranks of those airports deciding that well-trained agents are a much better shield than numbskulls who can't get a job anywhere else, but who rely on technology that can be skirted.
#1903
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Between AUS, EWR, and YTO In a little twisty maze of airline seats, all alike.. but I wanna go home with the armadillo
Programs: CO, NW, & UA forum moderator emeritus
Posts: 35,385
I assume your belt doesn't contain metal. I always remove mine because it does. What about drawstrings on sweat pants? What about a cummerbund or a toupee? I'm sure the answers are all in the fine print somewhere.
It's also odd that you can't take a shortcut through the WTMD. It is it because your not setting it off would be embarrassing?
Agreed that it's all strange.
It's also odd that you can't take a shortcut through the WTMD. It is it because your not setting it off would be embarrassing?
Agreed that it's all strange.
#1904
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: ATL Lost Luggage
Programs: Kettle with Kryptonium Medallion Tags
Posts: 10,280
The proper answer to that is "No, I do not, since your employer refuses to allow any independent reviews of these machines and their hazards... so that is why I am opting-out."
#1905
Join Date: Mar 2008
Programs: AAPLT, RR Alist
Posts: 220
Flew through Seattle the other day. Rude SOB at the front, "Do you actually understand how these machines work?" as if I was an idiot. Asked if I consented to a search. I replied as long as it didn't touch my genitals. He read from a card that included "We will not purposefully touch your genital area." Note the word purposefully. Had a little ollllllllddddd Asian do the pat down. Very thorough and conscientious. Talked me up more than felt me up. Noticed that most of the gropers were now small and old - I suppose that's less threatening (certainly better than the previous demographic that was at SEA). Very encouraged to see that the pat-down lines were FULL and being used consistently. Maybe people ARE waking up.
We'll use LaGuardia instead of JFK or Long Island from now on. No naked scanners. Instead, there are the usual metal detectors, a LOT of TSA personnel, and random checks. As soon as a booth is open, someone is randomly selected. They're inside the booth for about 4 minutes; I noticed at least three agents studying me while in there. Then those randomly selected are selected again for either swab, wand, or full patdown. What I observed was that elderly were wanded, women were swabbed, and men were selected for the full monty. It was very fast, and I thought very secure. LGA has apparently joined the ranks of those airports deciding that well-trained agents are a much better shield than numbskulls who can't get a job anywhere else, but who rely on technology that can be skirted.
We'll use LaGuardia instead of JFK or Long Island from now on. No naked scanners. Instead, there are the usual metal detectors, a LOT of TSA personnel, and random checks. As soon as a booth is open, someone is randomly selected. They're inside the booth for about 4 minutes; I noticed at least three agents studying me while in there. Then those randomly selected are selected again for either swab, wand, or full patdown. What I observed was that elderly were wanded, women were swabbed, and men were selected for the full monty. It was very fast, and I thought very secure. LGA has apparently joined the ranks of those airports deciding that well-trained agents are a much better shield than numbskulls who can't get a job anywhere else, but who rely on technology that can be skirted.
Pat down lanes are full because people are opting out? Or people not clearing AIT and getting a resolution patdown? I pass through SEA a lot and my limited observation is that a lot of people get both the AIT and patdown.