Trip Reports - A College Student goes back to New York for Thanksgiving (on AA)




CMK10
Dec 1, 04, 11:22 pm
Background
As many of you may know, I attend Arizona State University in Tempe, Arizona. However I am a New Yorker by birth and my family still makes their living in The Empire State. As there are 2,153 miles between them and their beloved eldest son, they require my presence a few times a year. Arguably the most important of those times is Thanksgiving. Perhaps they are thankful to have me, I mean who wouldn’t be? I am thankful to have them, I am also thankful that living out here affords me the opportunity to fly home. I decided to make my brother James thankful on this trip as I routed myself through Detroit so we could fly the same flight home. So it was off to go back to the cold confines of Suburban New York where the warm bastion of my family awaited me. Frankly, the turkey had better be good.

Preflight
WEDNESDAY NOVEMBER 24, 2004
American Flight 1032
PHX-DFW
Scheduled Departure: 7:55 AM
Scheduled Board: 7:25 PM

Today dawned cold and worrisome for your humble narrator. The weather in New York was forecasted to include rain and thunderstorms, the Midwest including Detroit was showing rain, snow and wind and two of my aircraft were coming in from other cities involving short turn arounds. As I sat eating my cereal, I postulated my fate and how best to master my own destiny. However when it comes to weather problems, all you can do is a combination of praying and hoping. After sufficient worrying, I made my way out the door and saddled up my old Montero for the short trip to the airport. After the humiliating experience of waiting at a metered on-ramp, I reached my first waypoint, the East Economy Lot at PHX. However I was met with a tersely worded sign saying “Closed – Use Upper Level of Terminal 2 Garage - $5 per day”. That was fine by me; the garage was closer to where I wanted to be. On my way in to park, a woman was checking off how many cars were coming in, when I asked she said only 120 spots remained. This was at 6:15 on the Wednesday of Thanksgiving, God help anyone trying to park tomorrow.

After a short shuttle bus ride, I made it to the First Class counter at PHX. The chances of getting a friendly and helpful agent are about one in two. However luck was on my side today as I got a nice woman who told me to remind my brother James that Ohio had pounded the tar out of his University of Michigan. After promises that I would do that, I made my way upstairs and through the standard security rigamole. The gate scenes today at Phoenix would have been laughable had I not had to endure them. People were camped out in nearly every available seat armed with as much carryon luggage money could buy. Fights over seats seemed on the cusp of occurring and already the savvy Frequent Flyers had taken up choice standing positions by the doorway. Once there they eyed anyone who came near looking for the words “First” or “Group 1”. I got lucky and snagged a choice seat from which I made calls to home and informed parental units that I’d probably be delayed. My dad then made the heavy hearted decision to send a cab to pick me up, instead of him doing it. I was cut to the quick.

About five minutes before boarding, while all the cries of “please check to make sure your bag can fit in our small overhead bins” were raging, I decided to join everyone else by the doorway. Once up there the gate agents asked for a volunteer for the usual $200 voucher and “The next available flight to Dallas”. As I had no idea when that would be and I actually had an agenda upon reaching my destination, I decided to not take the bait. Fortunately for me, neither did anyone else and this broadcast was followed by another one, saying “will Charles (pause) Koo-nts please come to the service desk.” Once there I was informed they needed my seat in coach so I was getting the wily and elusive operational upgrade. I was so consumed by glee of my 23 row catapult forward; I declined to admonish the gate agent for butchering my last name so badly. It’s Koo-nz people! New Boarding pass in hand, I was the last of the 22 people to board holding passes for the secluded F cabin of:

Flying
Gate 2
Seat 2E First Class
Ex-TWA 757-200, N711ZX
Actual Board: 7:33 AM
Actual Depart: 8:00 AM – 5 Minutes Delayed
Take off 10 minutes after departure

Even though I don’t like aisle seats, I happily sat down next to a rather dour man who seemed to regard me as someone not worthy of sharing row 2 with him. Don’t even try to annoy me, buddy, it’s been a great month and my trip is already starting out well. During the boarding process, I encountered something I’d never before seen on a full flight. The flight attendants brought around a tray of water and Orange Juice. Everytime before this I’ve been on a flight that was 95% or more full that didn’t board via Door 2, the FA’s stayed in the galley hiding from the onslaught of human cargo. But not today, Pam and J.C. set the tone early for a great crew. They have subsequently been rewarded by an email from me to American. After the lengthy boarding process during which I noticed several fellow Sun Devils on the flight, we pushed back. The take off afforded me my first opportunity to have reservations about returning home. There are reasons I ran as far away from my family as possible, hopefully those issues will remain dormant during this trip.

Once airborne, after the usual repertoire of PA messages that any FTer could recite backwards, a drinks cart was pushed into the aisle. This seemed a bit bizarre to me and I figured it would make its way back into the rear cabin, but in fact all beverages in F were served from it. I had never seen anything like this before and it seemed less classy than what I prefer in F, but when you’re on an upgraded N-fare ticket, you keep your whining to yourself. I pulled out a stack of articles relating to aviation I receive every week from my father and began to read about Delta’s problems while sipping my Cran-Apple. After about 20 minutes, during which the man next to me kept shooting me bizarre looks (he must be jealous of my good features) another cart inched towards the aisle. This time the cart bore foodstuffs and even though I had eaten previously at my apartment, I can’t turn down a Southwestern Omlette. It seemed few others could resist the cheese omlette atop potatoes, beans and salsa served with raisin bagels or biscuits and a fruit plate with grapefruit, kiwi, strawberry and oranges because only two people didn’t order meals and all plates were returned empty. The meal really is the best Domestic airline breakfast I’ve had and I’ve tried to make it at home but it just isn’t the same. After the meal I expected Pam and J.C. to head back to the comfortable confines of the forward galley but they shocked me and several other passengers by remaining mobile and dispensing drinks and smiles to all who looked thirsty. I was given my choice beverage of Baileys and coffee which warmed me all the way down. The rest of the flight passed much quicker than it would have had I been hidden in 25F, and before I knew it we were on the ground in Dollars, Taxes to quote Gaucho Marx.
Scheduled Arrival: 11:06 AM
Actual Arrival: 11:17 AM
Gate C32

Preflight/Transit
American Flight 1160
DFW-DTW
Scheduled Departure: 12:40 PM
Scheduled Board: 12:10 PM

I was lucky enough today to have a nearly identical connection to Spiff who was waiting for me in the Concourse C Admirals Club. For an hour instead of sitting alone, I enjoyed conversation about a variety of subjects from college life to aviation. He had been lucky enough to have his DFW-JFK flight upgraded to a 767-300 and he would be sitting pretty in the First Class cabin of that aircraft. I was unlucky enough to be in coach on an MD-80 that was coming in late from San Francisco. After sufficient bonding, we walked down the concourse together until I bade him goodbye outside gate C17 where I arrived a minute before boarding. After waiting for the motley First Class crew to board, I followed them onto:

Flying
Gate C17
Seat 8F Main Cabin
MD-80, N434AA
Actual Board: 12:32 PM
Actual Depart: 12:57 PM – 17 Minutes Delayed
Take off 10 minutes after departure

Another flight, another cabin chock full of merry revelers, most of whom don’t fly much. In front of me I had a couple who spent most of the flight in lip-lock and behind me I had a spoiled young girl who had the power to produce tears upon command. My heart went out to her father who tried in vein to have her be quiet. After takeoff I was able to subside her wails for coke and god knows what else with an influx of Guns n’ Roses via headphones.

The rest of the flight was as routine as most short-haul MD-80’s in coach. I got a full can of Dr. Pepper with a bag of salty pretzels. After a short while the FA’s collected the garbage and then retreated to the back of the plane where they could safely talk amongst themselves while we amused ourselves on this IFE-less aircraft. With an hour to go, I made my way to the back of the plane to take advantage of the excellent restrooms and I spotted a girl using her cell phone for text messaging, say it ain’t so, occupant of 27D. The flight up had offered views of the countryside for the first half of the ride, but as we neared Detroit, the weather began to turn rather foul. The captain elected to seat the crew earlier than usual, (not that it mattered, they were seated anyway) and we began our fateful decent into Mo-town. For the first twenty minutes of said decent, the only view offered was gray murky clouds that showed no sign of breaking. The drama was heightened by little Miss 9F who began to caterwaul as soon as we dipped below 37,000 feet. Finally just as most people began to worry the cloud layer was lower than advertised, landfall was achieved and a rain-slicked runway rose up to meet our aircraft. After a short taxi under dark and stormy skies (though it was not yet night) I emerged into the terminal to find my counterpart.
Scheduled Arrival: 4:15 PM
Actual Arrival: 4:17 PM
Gate B8

Preflight/Transit
American Eagle Flight 4883
DTW-LGA
Scheduled Departure: 6:00 PM
Scheduled Board: 5:30 PM

A little note on James here, he is one year my junior and attends the University of Michigan. While he hates all things flying and enjoys mocking my enjoyment of it, I still assert that we make a pretty good team. As we’ve always been rather close, our separation is less than enjoyable so I devise schemes to get us in the same place for x-treme bonding. Today was no exception as together we explored the decrepit L.C. Smith Terminal, ate Quizznos and weathered the storm while cracking loud jokes most people probably wished they didn’t have to hear.

As soon as I’d landed I knew there would be problems with this flight. Even in optimal conditions, the half hour turnaround the ERJ-140 is scheduled to make is questionable at best. With poor weather in New York and Detroit, I knew there would be issues. What we were treated to was a cascading delay as the plane didn’t arrive in Detroit until just before 7 PM. During that time we sat in a crowded waiting room listening to delays being announced for America West, American and Independence Air flights. The seats couldn’t have been more comfortable, in fact they’d been recently repaired with electrical tape! Finally after gate agents got most of the Chicago flight on their MD-80, we were allowed to board:

Flying
Gate B8
Seat 2A Main Cabin
ERJ-140
Actual Board: 6:53 PM
Actual Depart: 7:40 PM – 1 Hour 40 Minutes Delayed
Take off 47 minutes after departure

Frankly even an ERJ is a better place to camp out than the blasted L.C. Smith Terminal. I was lucky again to have another enjoyable flight attendant who kept the planeload of 44 people informed and amused and even managed to remain in a good mood. My heart went out to the guy, despite being from New York City; he would be spending his Thanksgiving in Raleigh-Durham, which meant he still had a flight to go that night. Even though we all boarded rapidly (during a delay, passengers seem to take minute amounts of times filing onboard, we had a paperwork crisis. The gate agents and rampers at Metro were harried so by the time we had everything we’d needed, the rain had turned to snow and the temperatures plummeted below the freezing mark. This could only mean a glycerol mixture being sprayed over the entire plane. We taxied out to the de-icing pad where we spent an agonizing 40 minutes during which no one could get up, including the flight attendant, or use a cellular phone. My poor family was expecting both my presence and that of my brother and I guarantee they were worried sick about us. Actually they probably forgot we existed but I like to pretend.

Finally after our dousing we got airborne. Once in the air we were treated to a cup of beverage and a serving of really stale Fisher pretzels. By then I had been sucking down heavily iced down drinks and eating old snacks for over fourteen hours and I was looking forward to the trip being over. We proceeded eastward in a timely manner, passing over Cleveland which looked amazing at night. James and I kept up our running dialogue as every-so-often I’d lean back and he’d lean forward (he was behind me in 3A) and we’d start a meaningless conversation. I’ve said it many times and this won’t be the last time, all his whining aside, he’s a good guy to travel with as he makes the flight enjoyable.

Soon I thought we were descending into New York, but it was only a 20 minute holding pattern. After that we began the real decent and I was back in New York State for the first time in over 3 months. Even though I was ready to start swashbuckling in my home state, it was not ready to have me. Due to weather and operations problems, there were two Eagle flights that had been more delayed than ours. Therefore we got to sit and watch them take the last two gates as we stewed. For 35 minutes we sat. Those 35 minutes consisted of me trying to explain to James why we couldn’t park at one of the open D gates. Just as I was contemplating a run for the terminal, we moved into D1. It couldn’t have come at a better time because I was running out of people to call up and whine to.
Scheduled Arrival: 8:00 PM
Actual Arrival: 10:49 PM
Gate D1

We made it outside and found our cab which took us up the coast to our suburban jungle where my father, aunt and her partner awaited us along with several siblings. For that moment at least we were hot commodities as hide nor hair had been seen of us in a while. We took advantage of being the center of attention while it lasted and had an enjoyable night.


CMK10
Dec 1, 04, 11:22 pm
--November 25, 2004 – Rye, NY --
Finally the biggest turkey day of the year had arrived, and I didn’t wake up until noon. The day was spent by all named Kunz enjoying each others company whether that be by wolfing down Thanksgiving food, watching football or playing Halo. At 9 PM I left them for a tearful (in theory anyway) reunion with my friends for a rousing game of Texas Hold ‘Em Poker.

--November 26, 2004 – Rye, NY --
Today was more of the same except my Uncle joined us and we ate good New York Style pizza. I don’t care how good your local joint is, you cannot beat a slice of pizza from The Empire State. Once again I headed over to see the friends and play poker while we caught up with each other. I can’t ask for better friends in New York.

--November 27, 2004 – Rye, NY--
Today everyone who wasn’t in the immediate family left and the original Kunz’s were left to love, honor and cherish each other in the style they saw fit. This style was mainly sleeping, playing Halo and eating leftovers. That night I saw my New York friends for the final time that November. We promised to write often and send much love over the miles, until we meet again in December.

Preflight
SUNDAY NOVEMBER 28, 2004
American Flight 731
LGA-DFW
Scheduled Departure: 10:00 AM
Scheduled Board: 9:30 AM

I awoke from an interrupted four hours sleep feeling bittersweet about my day ahead. On one hand I had the wonderful new life I’d built for myself in Arizona, complete with an excellent girl friend ahead of me. However, I was leaving some damned good friends and some decent family behind me. Still, I can’t exactly quit college and move into my parent’s basement so I grabbed the bags, hugged the fam, and entered the rainy morning to blaze a trail to New York’s LaGuardia Airport. I had booked James on a 9:50 nonstop to Detroit and myself on a 10 AM to Dallas to make my dad’s life easier as he had to play chauffer. The whole way to the airport he kept staring nervously at the rainy skies and telling us “you guys are gonna be delayed!” You have to love pessimistic people; it is so much fun to prove them wrong. After an uneventful 25 minute drive to the airport fraught with tearful goodbyes, James and I entered a world gateway on the busiest day of the year.

I have to say I was expecting more than this. There weren’t any lines at any American counters, plenty of ticket machines stood unused and my shoes made echoing noises in the empty check-in lobby. But I don’t mind, I’ll take a delay free journey. Soon enough I had boarding passes for the Elitist Snob (me) and the Commoner (James) and we headed through the D Concourse check point to lounge at the Admirals Club. Once there we ate bagels, drank juice and coffee and did our best to stay awake. As college kids we aren’t used to waking up in the AM and as James hates flying, he had no motivation to be awake. Soon enough 9:15 rolled around and I walked him back to the checkpoint as he’d have to go over to C for his ER3 and I’d remain at D2 for my S80. As we’re big men, we kept the tears inside, but I know each of us died a little that day. I was hoping for a bump as my flight was oversold by two, but the gate agent said that would be unnecessary. However, when you have a flight that will have upwards of 130 people on it, why put it at a gate with less than 50 seats? The place resembled a refugee camp with people and luggage strewn everywhere. I joined them in a choice spot on the floor before boarding:

Flying
Gate D2
Seat 9A Main Cabin
MD-80 N446AA
Actual Board: 9:30 AM
Actual Depart: 9:58 AM – 2 Minutes Early
Take off 21 minutes after departure

I made my way towards the back of the plane with my right hand clutching a white bag of wonder. This was otherwise known as the lunch on today’s nearly four hour flight. As the plane filled up, I sat and prayed for someone petite to be seated next to me as I am built like a linebacker, not a ballerina and I didn’t want petty fights for space to rage. Thankfully I got lucky and a woman of thin build was seated next to me. As we waited for everyone to find a bin (those lucky enough to do so) I watched as N714AE pushed back and headed for greener pastures in Detroit. So long James, see you in just under a month. Once again my father was proven wrong (believe it or not, C. Thomas Kunz the Third is NOT always correct) as we left early and after an 8 plane back up on the outer runway, we were going back to The Lone Star State.

Once after takeoff, even though I couldn’t wait to dive into my Bistro Bag, I took a quick nap. However my body won’t allow me to go without gourmet food for too long, as it woke me up once the beverage cart made it to my row. Armed with a Diet Coke, I devoured my turkey and cheese sandwich, Ruffles plain potato chips, carrots and a brownie. Honestly, the food isn’t too bad; there just isn’t enough of it. Today’s growing boy needs a larger sandwich and perhaps a piece of fruit as well. Once that was done, it was time for me to get serious. I pulled out the laptop, affixed my Bose Noise Canceling Headsets (thanks Dad) to my head and began to work. After typing out a stellar piece on FDR, I edited a friend of mine’s paper in which he misspelled “from its” as “fro tits”. Following that, I grabbed Politics books by the handful and began to read in earnest about how there was almost a party realignment during the Wilson Administration. Thank God there wasn’t or I’d have had more reading to do. I have to compliment the crew on this flight; they dished out three different beverage services and stayed up in the aisles far more than the crew on the way to Detroit had. I and many other passengers appreciated the extra sodie pop as it keeps us hyper. Soon however it was time to say howdy y’all to Texas as we made our way to the C terminal slightly early.
Scheduled Arrival: 1:07 PM
Actual Arrival: 1:03 PM
Gate D1

Preflight/Transit
American Flight 1471
DFW-PHX
Scheduled Departure: 1:55 PM
Scheduled Board: 1:25 PM

For the second year in a row on Thanksgiving, I was left with a tight connection at Dallas. Back then I’d only had an 18 gate trek and a First Class seat on a meal flight had awaited me. This time I had to go a whole terminal plus 22 gates and I had a bag of pretzels with my name on it. Therefore my first order of business was to feed myself, but I wanted to get it done somewhere near my gate. As I had under an hour I was forced, against my better judgment, to ride the TrAAin. Along with multiple other passengers, we braced ourselves for possible mortal injury and rattled our way through the bowels of DFW. Thankfully I made it to the A13 stop alive and well and decided to try and change that with voluntary Taco Bell ingestion. After getting my bag of faux Mexican Food I made it to Gate A11 (the furthest into the depths of A I have ever been) and boarded:

Flying
Gate A11
Seat 21A Main Cabin - Exit Row
MD-80 N454AA
Actual Board: 1:25 PM
Actual Depart: 1:52 PM – 3 Minutes Early
Take off 10 minutes after departure

I made my way towards the back of my aircraft once again clutching sustenance, but this time it was at least hot. However before I could dine, I had to call my girl friend as I’d promised to do that, and every guy who’s taken out there knows what happens if we break promises. After sufficient cooing at each other, I was free to eat as we taxied out and began my final leg of flying for a while. Once in the air I strapped my new headphones back on and got back to work on my Politics reading. Having polished off two books, I embarked onto my third. Even though I was heavily caffeinated due to over 40 ounces of Diet Coke on the day, I fell back into a doze. Unfortunately, once I woke up the time shifting, bad weather and food abuse I’d put into my body took its toll and I felt sick. This feeling has since not abated. Thankfully we were thirty minutes out of Phoenix and I was able to put my book away and watch the desert turn into lush city with the panoramic ASU campus winking up at me. Soon we were back in Aree-zona and I headed off in search of an old blue SUV into which my key would fit. It was a good vacation, perhaps my most successful trip home yet, but it was great to be back at sunset’s gate.
Scheduled Arrival: 3:31 PM
Actual Arrival: 3:22 PM
Gate 2

Seat 2A
Dec 2, 04, 6:22 am
Let me be the first to say Thanks for yet another stellar effort, Charles. Your reports have an interesting and entertaining flavor what with the references to school, family and life in general. I assume you've a multi-stop epic planned for your journey home at Christmas?

By the way, now that you're Platinum with AAdvantage, have you had very good luck with the 72 hour upgrades?


dhammer53
Dec 2, 04, 7:39 am
Today was more of the same except my Uncle joined us and we ate good New York Style pizza. I don’t care how good your local joint is, you cannot beat a slice of pizza from The Empire State.


And don't you forget it! :D

If you want to meet me at Sal's in Mamaroneck, let me know. I'm available after 12/12.

PresRDC
Dec 2, 04, 9:53 am
Another great report and, as always, a pleasure to read.

Brings back fond memories of my own SBN-ORD-HPN/LGA-ORD-SBN Thanksgiving routings.

I noticed that you always fly into LGA, but HPN has to be much closer for you. Any reason why you avoid it?

Doppy
Dec 2, 04, 4:53 pm
So how is the last name pronounced?

CMK10
Dec 6, 04, 8:42 pm
Seat2A Since becoming a Plat I have never missed a sticker upgrade. I only came close once when I had to pick up my boarding pass at the gate 40 minutes before my flight.

PresRDC HPN is too expensive for me, the fares are usually twice as high as LGA and JFK and they have limited options which just the ORD arrivals. It is a great airport to fly into, back in the day what was the equipment on your ORD-HPN flights?

PresRDC
Dec 7, 04, 10:41 am
PresRDC HPN is too expensive for me, the fares are usually twice as high as LGA and JFK and they have limited options which just the ORD arrivals. It is a great airport to fly into, back in the day what was the equipment on your ORD-HPN flights?

Truth be told, back then my mommy was making my travel plans and I was not given the choice. Price dictated. As such, I flew whoever she selected into HPN. Usually, it was Delta (Comair) on a CRJ routing SBN-CVG-HPN (sometimes the SBN-CVG would be on a 737-200) or Northwest on a DC-9-30 routing SBN-DTW-HPN or, in rare cases, United on a 737-500 routing SBN-ORD-HPN. That said, when I flew into LGA (about a quarter of the time), it was always on American via ORD. By law school, I was making my own travel plans, but by then Eagle had pulled out of SBN, so AA was a less desireable option (I did try driving to FWA once to fly AA, but considered it too much of a hassle for too few miles).

I did once fly HPN-ORD-BWI-ORD-HPN when AA was using the F100s, but I had already started working by then.

I can even remember flying on United 737-200s HPN-ORD-HPN with my Dad for our annual Notre Dame football weekend when I was a kid. Fun stuff.



SEO by vBSEO 3.2.0