US Airways Dividend Miles (Pre-FlightFund Merger) - No Flly List Mismatch (and check-in agts aren't really that stupid)




Dont call me Shirley
Aug 20, 04, 5:55 pm
Both the NY Times and Wash Post today had stories about Sen Edward Kennedy being delayed in boarding because his name (along with anyone else by that name) hitting as a match on the no fly list.

http://www.nytimes.com/2004/08/20/national/20flight.html?hp
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A17073-2004Aug19.html

Both articles say that "ticket agents" refused to allow the Senator to board until supervisors interceeded. The WaPo piece, written by a journalist one of whose specialties is aviation security, implies that the agents did not regognize the Senator. Both papers recount that the agents told the Senator that they could not state the reason for the delay in check-in. This is actually correct; airline staff are prohibited from stating the reason when check-in is denied or delayed due to a possible No-Fly list match, per the Feds.

I am disappointed that of two nation's leading papers would make it appear that the issue is up to the agents; when a possible match is detected, the computer system actually inhibits check-in, even if the mismatch is obvious.
Only certain employees (usually, not always supervisors) have the level of computer access needed to clear and override possible match.
Had someone less recognizable than Ted Kennedy been flagged, additional time would have been involved as the supervisor took the steps needed to ensure that the match was indeed false.

Maybe, I am being overly sensitive. But I can just imagine readers shaking their heads and muttering "stupid airline agents". Yeah sometimes check-in staff can do some supid things. Most of then are not that stupid, however.

Even when a customer is flagged as a selectee by CAPPS, airline staff can not make an exception based on common sense, only under very specific and definesd circumstances.


StSebastian
Aug 22, 04, 1:37 am
I'm moderately flagged by CAPPS and majorly flagged by INS systems. If I have an FF number then I can usually get past CAPPS, but I get selected every time if something gets changed about my ticket. INS stops me every time I come back to the US now.

I always have to go to secondary for INS, and then get cleared pretty quickly, so that's just part of the system. I think it's irritating to deal with, but I have a pretty common name and since some people have their panties in a wad over looking at personal characteristics rather than just name matching, I'm stuck with being flagged. Now that they've told me a bit about where it is happening, I can joke with the INS agents in the primary and secondary locations. It is obvious to them that I'm not who they want (at least wrong race, height, age, and weight from what I've learned), but the policies in place require I go through each of the steps to get cleared. I know what it is, so I go through the hoops, but it could be really frightening for someone that's not used to it and has no idea what's going on.

I'm glad it happened to someone and made the news -- maybe some people will realize the current process of name matching isn't the best way to implement what they want to ultimately do, if that message gets out with these news stories. I love the quote from someone who knows a little bit more about security: "The United States does not have a security system, it has a system for bothering people."



SEO by vBSEO 3.2.0