American Express Membership Rewards - AmEx Premier Rewards Gold Card match better offer?

Am EXP PMG Card
Hi I have a premier gold card. I was watching this thread on the 50,000 and 1000 spend w/3months.May 23 I applied for a 25000 and 2000 spend w/3months.I still haven't activated it. I called AME to try to get the upgrade. I got sent to the miles reward dept. She said to be able to get "considered" for the upgrade I would have to meet the first offer.And if I cancel the card I'd have a chance of all my AME cards getting canceled.
Can anybody shed some wisdom on this .

Welcome to Flyertalk. I have edited the thread title for clarity.

Why did you apply if you were not satisfied with the offer? American Express has no duty to match offers which were made to others.

Why do you believe that American Express would cancel your other cards if you close this account?

At one time, Amex was very liberal about matching offers, but that has turned around 180 degrees.

Also note that the 50K offer is (I think) targeted. They generally will not match a targeted offer.

At this point, I would put little or no faith in anything their Membership Rewards department says, at least on this particular issue. (I assume that's what you meant when you said "Miles Rewards.") This department does not have the authority to issue bonus adjustments anyway.

Welcome to Flyertalk. I have edited the thread title for clarity.

Why did you apply if you were not satisfied with the offer? American Express has no duty to match offers which were made to others.

Why do you believe that American Express would cancel your other cards if you close this account?
I don't understand your question Why did you apply if you were not satisfied with the offer?
If I see a better opportunity,I'm going to try to get it.
I spoke to a rep when I inquired about "bumping" me up to the 50000 bonus.The rep in the point awards dept. said "I would have to adhere to the first offer" and then call to see if I could be considered to be eligible for the better promo and if I decided to cancel the card because for "what ever reason",there was a chance I could have all my AMX cards be cancelled on me.

At one time, Amex was very liberal about matching offers, but that has turned around 180 degrees.

Also note that the 50K offer is (I think) targeted. They generally will not match a targeted offer.

At this point, I would put little or no faith in anything their Membership Rewards department says, at least on this particular issue. (I assume that's what you meant when you said "Miles Rewards.") This department does not have the authority to issue bonus adjustments anyway.

Yes Miles Reward Dept is what I meant .I didn't realize that they wouldn't match a targeted offer.

At one time, Amex was very liberal about matching offers.

This was also a very brief time, not representative of American Express's longterm practice.

At one time, Amex was very liberal about matching offers, but that has turned around 180 degrees.

Also note that the 50K offer is (I think) targeted. They generally will not match a targeted offer.

At this point, I would put little or no faith in anything their Membership Rewards department says, at least on this particular issue. (I assume that's what you meant when you said "Miles Rewards.") This department does not have the authority to issue bonus adjustments anyway.

Agreed. The 50k bonus MR points is definitely a targeted offer. I wouldn't rely on Membership Rewards to credit the difference as the offer most likely did not originate from that department.

If I see a better opportunity,I'm going to try to get it.


Perhaps I misunderstood your initial post, but it sounded as if you had been watching the targeted offers reported in the forum, applied for the standard offer, and expected American Express to better it. This might happen, but one shouldn't apply unless prepared to accept the application offer.

It's similar to buying an airline ticket. Buy when the price is right for you. You can be assured some people on the same plane paid less, but that doesn't invalidate your purchase.

There's no benefit to delaying the activation of the card. The clock is already running on the three month qualification period. There are about two months remaining.

And if I cancel the card I'd have a chance of all my AME cards getting canceled.
Can anybody shed some wisdom on this .

I think one of the op questions was if he were to cancel his gold card,they might cancel his other AM/EX credit cards,,I never heard of this happening before,,,,has anyone else?

At one time, Amex was very liberal about matching offers, but that has turned around 180 degrees.

Also note that the 50K offer is (I think) targeted. They generally will not match a targeted offer.

At this point, I would put little or no faith in anything their Membership Rewards department says, at least on this particular issue. (I assume that's what you meant when you said "Miles Rewards.") This department does not have the authority to issue bonus adjustments anyway.

Actually... last time I had an issue where they woudnt issue my 50k for my plat. they kept saying MR cant assign point.
after 1 month of back and forth and having their twitter team said they would. I called one more time repeating the whole story, then put me on hold and said that he issued 50k points in my account... They are just using the "cant do it" as a cameo me thinks...