Caribbean - Seven Stars (Turks&Caicos) v Viceroy (Anguilla)

All things being equal, where would you go. Mrs Rumph and I are ready to pull the trigger on a trip in june and cant decide between the two. Fares, rooms, all are about the same price.
Any comments, opinions would be appreciated.
Thanks

I have stayed at Seven Stars on one of my multiple business trips to Provo. I've been to Anguilla, but not to the resort you mentioned.

I stayed at Seven Stars during a shoulder season. The resort was less than 50% occupied. Rooms are essentially small apartments complete with kitchens. Spectacular bathroom. Internet was iffy. Restaurant service was excellent, but it was expensive. Nice thing about Provo is that there are lots of dining options, including several within walking distance.

Anguilla is smaller, and much, much quieter. It is also harder to get to as you will need to transit in SJU, ANU or SXM. From SXM you can catch a flight or a ferry.

It depends on what you are looking for. Both places have nice beaches and good snorkeling/diving.
--
13F

Thank you for your comments. I think we've settled on Anguilla, ex NYC to SXM is quite cheap for our dates, and the very quiet and laid back is more of what we're looking for. We did, however, vow to try the Seven Stars in the future.