TalkBoard Topics - Removal of police and other public official names from postings?




marklyon
Aug 8, 11, 5:43 am
It appears that a number of posts, including one of my recent threads (http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/travel-safety-security/1245208-jfk-t4-assaulted-tso-filming-forced-delete.html), has been significantly altered by removing the names of police officers and other public officials involved in incidents.

It is difficult to understand why this is occurring. This does not appear to be supported by the policy (http://www.flyertalk.com/help/rules.php#q69):

With the exception of public figures, do not post names, addresses, phone numbers or e-mails of other FlyerTalk members. This information will be removed by moderators. Respect the privacy of non-management travel service employees by not referring to them by name.

The people referred to in my post are public figures and management-level employees. Publishing the names of wrongdoers is a legitimate action. Further, Flyertalk's ability to shield itself from claims under §230 could be weakened if moderators continue to be so heavily involved in modification and editing of threads.

I petition the TalkBoard to clarify the policy posted above and ask that moderators reserve heavy-handed editing for instances where same is truly appropriate, for instance, revealing personal information about another poster.

Thank you.


Spiff
Aug 8, 11, 5:50 am
This is a moderation issue, not TalkBoard's purview.

I suggest contacting the moderator(s) in question.

DeaconFlyer
Aug 8, 11, 6:04 am
This is a moderation issue, not TalkBoard's purview.

I suggest contacting the moderator(s) in question.

Don't bother. They are only accountable to the Community Director. Go straight to her.


marklyon
Aug 8, 11, 10:28 am
If you guys are not here to impact policy on the forums, what do you do? (I admit, I haven't really paid too much attention to the TalkBoard, since I thought things were rolling along rather smoothly)

Spiff
Aug 8, 11, 1:08 pm
If you guys are not here to impact policy on the forums, what do you do? (I admit, I haven't really paid too much attention to the TalkBoard, since I thought things were rolling along rather smoothly)

What is TalkBoard? (http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/talkboard-topics/918161-what-talkboard-how-new-forums-other-suggestions-considered.html)

Moderator2
Aug 8, 11, 8:04 pm
As the OP has been given background on how to address this, I'm closing the thread.



SEO by vBSEO ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.