Caribbean - Question about St. John Accommodation

We're planning on going to St. John around Thanksgiving. I was looking at accommodation and would prefer not to stay at the Westin or another place in Cruz Bay. Does anyone have any recommendations of any villas/houses to stay in? I've been checking out a few places in Coral Bay, but wanted to see if anyone else had any other recommendations for a reasonable priced place. I know we would plan on renting a vehicle whilst there and do snorkeling, go to the beach, etc. (obviously!) :)

Too late for your needs; but, we stayed at Maho Bay Camps during our visit to St. John and I HIGHLY recomend them as well as the Concordia sister property.