My vote goes hands down to Le Bernadin.

mpclaw,

Wonderfully divisive topic! Personally, I would vote for Nobu or Peter Luger. Of course, I also happen to be a big fan of Le Bernadin.

All three are fine restaurants :-) OUr our lovely city there are NO overrated restaurants - just Overpriced restaurants. I remember in the early '80s when $100 Kobe beef was in the news, every local station did a piece on it - reporters making trips to OldHomestead.....looking for folks who had ordered....So -- No overraed - just Overpriced ;-)

Tavern on the Green

Mesa Grill

------------------
Who is John Galt?
------------------

Nobu and Indochine.