Ok, I need a one way ticket for two people. So currently for the times for my flights (1/4/02 morning) it's gonna be about $450+ for a one way. DOes anybody know of any charter companies? I can't imagine they would be any more than that for the very-very short flight.

I would suggest you go to the www.traveltalkonline.com (http://www.traveltalkonline.com) boards.

These are the boards for Caribbean travel. There are more options than what you have booked. That looks like an American Eagle rate.

Those guys would have additional suggestions.....Air Sunshine, St. Thomas Air, etc.