Advice needed: Problem with A3 flight leading to long delay
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: Europe
Posts: 216
Advice needed: Problem with A3 flight leading to long delay
Hello everyone!
I would really appreciate your opinion on this. I had the following delay/problem on 12 Jan 2017:
A37101 (domestic SKG-ATH)
Original Departure time: 06:30
Actual Departure time: 09:30
DELAY: 3 hours (reason: multiple passengers wanter to get off the plane after 1 hour of waiting for takeoff)
Connection to A3616 missed.
Rerouted from SKG-ATH-AMS to SKG-ATH-BRU-AMS
Journey original arrival time 11:25
Journey actual arrival time 19:20
TOTAL DELAY TO DESTINATION 7 hours & 55 minutes
(By the way, baggage lost and delivered at the hotel after 24 hours...)
So for this almost 8 hour delay, what they offered in Athens was a free domestic ticket and a lunch voucher.
Do you think I should contact them for a better compensation since this ended up in an almost 8 hours delay to get from SKG to ASM?
Any advice highly appreciated!
Thanks
I would really appreciate your opinion on this. I had the following delay/problem on 12 Jan 2017:
A37101 (domestic SKG-ATH)
Original Departure time: 06:30
Actual Departure time: 09:30
DELAY: 3 hours (reason: multiple passengers wanter to get off the plane after 1 hour of waiting for takeoff)
Connection to A3616 missed.
Rerouted from SKG-ATH-AMS to SKG-ATH-BRU-AMS
Journey original arrival time 11:25
Journey actual arrival time 19:20
TOTAL DELAY TO DESTINATION 7 hours & 55 minutes
(By the way, baggage lost and delivered at the hotel after 24 hours...)
So for this almost 8 hour delay, what they offered in Athens was a free domestic ticket and a lunch voucher.
Do you think I should contact them for a better compensation since this ended up in an almost 8 hours delay to get from SKG to ASM?
Any advice highly appreciated!
Thanks
#4
Community Director
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Norwich, UK
Programs: A3*G, BA Gold, BD Gold (in memoriam), IHG Diamond Ambassador
Posts: 8,476
I suspect this may still depend on the reason for the initial delay. If that was for weather or ATC, the OP might have a fight to claim EC261 delay compensation - the off-loading wouldn't have happened if the initial problem hadn't existed, so A3 would probably claim the root cause was extraordinary, even if their later decision to allow off-loading exacerbated the delay. I'm not aware there's any definitive case law that would help here.
If it wasn't weather, it's extremely clear-cut - everything would then be under A3's control and compensation would definitely be payable. There would then be no question that the initial cause was down to A3, and it would have been their decision not to close the doors at a given point so no-one else could choose to leave. That's the Commander's decision more than anyone else's.
The delay time itself is certainly the doors open time at final destination - there is case law to this effect, so that's not in dispute.
If it wasn't weather, it's extremely clear-cut - everything would then be under A3's control and compensation would definitely be payable. There would then be no question that the initial cause was down to A3, and it would have been their decision not to close the doors at a given point so no-one else could choose to leave. That's the Commander's decision more than anyone else's.
The delay time itself is certainly the doors open time at final destination - there is case law to this effect, so that's not in dispute.
#5
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Netherlands
Programs: KL Platinum; A3 Gold
Posts: 28,713
You start from SKG. You want to finish in AMS.
I can't see any scenario in which the "delay" in getting to, or departing from, any intermediate waypoint (that you didn't actually need to be at) has any bearing on anything. Your journey was not to ATH, and the only reason you went to ATH at all is because this is how A3 routed you. The "delay" as seen from ATH therefore has no bearing whatsoever - it was not the place you needed or wanted to be.
(The above is written from the assumption that you had a single, A3-issued ticket. If, instead, you were travelling SKG-ATH and ATH-AMS on separate tickets, even if both tickets were on A3, then this changes the matter very significantly).
#7
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Netherlands
Programs: KL Platinum; A3 Gold
Posts: 28,713
#8
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Heraklion, Greece
Posts: 7,565
@lgts: although you write nothing about it, isn't this all related to last Saturday's snow storm? Well, you're sort of lucky that you did make it to your final destination. Several planes (A3 and Ryanair) that made it to Chania could not get out of there for a day (ice and snow), and North of Crete they had more than 40 cm of snow in other places, including islands (up to 80 cm on Skopelos and Alonissos). Only the extreme Northwest of the country was spared... Still anyone thinks EC261 is due?
#9
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Netherlands
Programs: KL Platinum; A3 Gold
Posts: 28,713
#10
Original Poster
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: Europe
Posts: 216
@lgts: although you write nothing about it, isn't this all related to last Saturday's snow storm? Well, you're sort of lucky that you did make it to your final destination. Several planes (A3 and Ryanair) that made it to Chania could not get out of there for a day (ice and snow), and North of Crete they had more than 40 cm of snow in other places, including islands (up to 80 cm on Skopelos and Alonissos). Only the extreme Northwest of the country was spared... Still anyone thinks EC261 is due?
#11
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: LON, ATH
Programs: A3*G, BA Gold, OA Gold (in memoriam), Hertz #1 Gold
Posts: 547
@KLouis: According to the captain, the delay due to the weather was only 30 minutes (de-icing). The rest of the delay -which is the reason for the missed connection- was due to unloading luggage and people who one-by-one were deciding not to fly that day. So, yes, the weather was not good at all, but the delay was not due to that. Please note that at least 3 take-offs took place while we where on the apron waiting for people to get off the plane.
#12
Community Director
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Norwich, UK
Programs: A3*G, BA Gold, BD Gold (in memoriam), IHG Diamond Ambassador
Posts: 8,476
@KLouis: According to the captain, the delay due to the weather was only 30 minutes (de-icing). The rest of the delay -which is the reason for the missed connection- was due to unloading luggage and people who one-by-one were deciding not to fly that day. So, yes, the weather was not good at all, but the delay was not due to that. Please note that at least 3 take-offs took place while we where on the apron waiting for people to get off the plane.
The purpose of the legislation is that airlines are held responsible for delays that are within their control.
In this case, there was a delay due to adverse weather. Subsequently some passengers decided they no longer wished to fly. Assuming the latter issue was not caused by A3 deliberately choosing to return to the terminal multiple times when it could instead have trundled down the runway and taken off, which clearly is not what happened because the plane remained on the apron (presumably just outside the terminal building if a typical SKG operation), neither of these are incidents within the airline's control. It would therefore be perfectly sensible for A3 to claim extraordinary circumstances.
You are on an absolute hiding to nothing on this one.
#13
Join Date: Jul 2013
Location: GIB BCN LUX MLA GOT LCA ATH
Programs: Miles and More FTL; Miles and Bonus *G; Emirates
Posts: 94
#15
You calculate the total distance origin to destination hence SKG-AMS without the intermediate points.
it would be €400, but I think it's extraordinary as none of this would have happened had the snow not been there and de-icing needed.
it would be €400, but I think it's extraordinary as none of this would have happened had the snow not been there and de-icing needed.