View Single Post
Old Nov 12, 11, 2:17 pm   #184
nabeelj
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: YYZ
Programs: AA LT Plat, A3 *S, Hyatt/IHG Plat, Carlson/SPG Gold, Marriott/Hilton Silver, National Exec, Hertz 5*
Posts: 889
Quote:
Originally Posted by nabeelj View Post
Am I just imagining things, or were these points worth ~1.6c before? They now seem to be worth 1.2-1.25c.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gerald5 View Post
Yes the points have been devalued by 22% with no prior communication. Disappointing.
I finally had some time to analyze this a bit:

So, first things first, where did I get my 1.6c value? Specifically, from three places:

1. PenFed Premium Rewards T&Cs give examples of redemption values, all of which come to 1.6c per point.
2. 5-10 tests (several months ago) of comparing simple flights to Travelocity and Expedia. I mostly compared AA and UA flights from YYZ and ORD to random cities. I got a valuation very close to 1.6c per point almost every time.
3. The program requires you to pay a minimum of 75% of the first ticket by points. If you try to pay cash for the 25% or for additional tickets, you quickly figure out the cost of the flight. Doing this several months ago resulted in a valuation of 1.6c per point.

Now, #1 hasn't changed, but #2 and #3 now result in 1.25c per point.

As such, 1-(1.25c/1.6c) = ~22% devaluation.
nabeelj is offline   Reply With Quote