I stayed at the Waldorf last week for the first time - I was upgraded to a junior suite (I'm diamond) and received 2 drink coupons. She did mention something about evian - I suppose that was the free two bottles from the fridge. They did have a special diamond area check in which I suppose is a nice touch.
I ended up needing to stay an extra night - but the rate would jump about $150 so I checked out and checked into the W. I had stayed at the W Tuscany & Court (STAY AT THE TUSCANY) and even though I knew the rooms at the W were small, I didn't expect them to be MICROSCOPIC. Very cool lounge/bar scene. Ironically, i had a view of the waldorf where I left my suite which was about 6 times the size of my W room (oh, I'm gold with starwood).
so next week i'm back at the W and the two weeks after that I'm at the Waldorf.