Well, I just got this today, guess that settles that.

I just did a redemption yesterday for the 2500 AA miles.
Dear Live Search Club Participant,
You are receiving this communication from Live Search Club because you recently placed a duplicate prize order with Live Search Club. As noted in our Terms and Conditions, prizes are limited to one of each prize per household. Your duplicate order for 2500 Frequent Flyer Miles has been cancelled and 4,300 tickets have been re-issued to the account from which the duplicate prize order was placed. We are sending this email to let you know that tickets have been re-issued to your account and are ready for you to redeem for another prize of your choice in our Prize Mall.
Thank you for being a loyal Live Search Club participant!
Kind Regards,
The Live Search Club Support
Please do not reply to this email, this is an unmonitored alias.
However, when I checked my account, I'm still down 4 the tickets for 4 other missing redemptions, 2 x 2500 AA, 1 x 500 AA, and 1 x 1000 AA.